top of page
Search

108. Six Hundred Years: The Origin of the Sexagesimal System?

Oct 5
81 min read

Updated: Oct 14


We are so accustomed to measuring time in years, months, days, hours, minutes and seconds that it is easy to forget that this way of dividing up time and space was invented by someone, once. Why should an hour contain sixty minutes, and a minute sixty seconds? Why should a circle contain 360 degrees, with each degree again divided into sixty minutes and each minute into sixty seconds? Every time we look at a clock, read a geographical coordinate or measure an angle, we are still using the remnants of an extraordinarily ancient way of counting. How old? Maybe 5000 years or more...

Suppose you discover that a small integer possesses remarkable internal mathematical properties and that its multiples and powers also seem to organise the motions of the heavens. The obvious conclusion in a traditional cosmology might be that the number reveals something about the order of the cosmos itself.


Giovanni Domenico Cassini (8-11 June 1625 – 14 September 1712), Italian-French mathematician, astronomer, astrologer and engineer. Artist unknown.
Giovanni Domenico Cassini (8-11 June 1625 – 14 September 1712), Italian-French mathematician, astronomer, astrologer and engineer. Artist unknown.

The origins of this system are obscure. Sexagesimal mathematics are particularly associated with ancient Mesopotamia, where a sophisticated base-60 positional system was used, and its descendants passed into later Greek astronomy and ultimately into our own measurement of angles and time. But was its use much older and more widespread than is commonly thought? And why was sixty chosen in the first place? How were the various applications of sexagesimal reckoning developed?

One way into the problem is to forget, for a moment, the way we practise astronomy today. Ancient astronomy was above all a buisiness of cycles: seasons, years, months, etc. The Sun returns. The Moon waxes and wanes. Planets move about the sky. Eclipses return in recognisable patterns. Stars rise again at particular seasons. Some of these cycles are short enough to observe within a month or a year; others take decades, centuries or, at least in theory, thousands of years. The difficulty is that these celestial clocks do not keep the same time. A solar year is about 365.2422 days, while a synodic lunar month is about 29.53059 days. The Moon's return against the stars takes about 27.32166 days, while its return to perigee takes about 27.5545. The planets introduce still more periods. None divides neatly into the others. A calendar that could keep track of several of them at once, would have to focus on moments at which the different clocks come close to meeting again.


Berossus, a Babylonian priest of Bel/Marduk, historian and astronomer of the late fourth/early third century BC, active under the early Seleucids. He wrote his Babyloniaca in Greek, probably around the early third century BC, drawing on Babylonian material.
Berossus, a Babylonian priest of Bel/Marduk, historian and astronomer of the late fourth/early third century BC, active under the early Seleucids. He wrote his Babyloniaca in Greek, probably around the early third century BC, drawing on Babylonian material.

Some of the resulting numbers are familiar. Nineteen solar years correspond very closely to 235 synodic lunar months and 254 sidereal lunar month: the relationship we call the Metonic cycle. The Saros lasts a little over eighteen years and brings together 223 synodic months and nearly 239 anomalistic months. The eight-year cycle, or octaeteris, brings the Sun and Moon into a useful approximation in a relatively short period of time, and has the additional attraction of being very close

to five synodic cycles of Venus. Ancient astronomy was full of such periods. They were ways of making several moving heavens calculable at once.

There were other cycles which are much less familiar today. One of the strangest is 600 years - strange in the sense of unfamiliar. It seems both foundational, the number 6 being a key part of ancient mathematics, and completely obscure. The number occurs in ancient traditions discussed by Josephus and other ancient writers, and was sufficiently puzzling to attract the attention of the great astronomer Giovanni Domenico Cassini. Josephus had called 600 years a “great year”, and Cassini realised that it made remarkable astronomical sense, being very close to 7421 lunar revolutions, so a means of reconciling the sun and moon, in much the same way as the Metonic cycle does. Curiously, it also seems to function as a period of 600 years of 360 computational days. In addition, there is also a cycle of 60 years that seems to have been complimentary to this longer cycle of 600 years. So what are these cycles all about?



Our Guides: Bailly and Le Gentil



Jean Sylvain Bailly (15 September 1736 – 12 November 1793), French astronomer, mathematician, freemason, and political leader of the early part of the French Revolution.. Portrait by Jean-Laurent Mosnier, 1789
Jean Sylvain Bailly (15 September 1736 – 12 November 1793), French astronomer, mathematician, freemason, and political leader of the early part of the French Revolution.. Portrait by Jean-Laurent Mosnier, 1789

Two figures from the eighteenth century can serve as invaluable guides to the strange world of ancient astrnomy, both French astronomers, both members of the Paris Royal Academy of Sciences: Jean-Sylvain Bailly (1736–1793) and Guillaume Le Gentil (1725–1792). They both have great stories, so before we get into the business of 600 years, it's worth introducing them. You may notice they both died during the French revolution, but only one was guillotined.

Le Gentil was one of many astronomers sent to the four corners of the earth, as part of a global effort to observe the 1761 transit of Venus. This was a key moment in science, and fom it is was hoped that the scale of the solar system could be determined. Le Gentil was posted to India. En route to Pondicherry, he met with one misfortune after another. Indeed, after a momentous journey, when the destination was finally reached, war having broken out between the French and the English, and the city having been recaptured by the British, he was unable to set foot on land. As a result, he couldn't make his observations from the required place. Rather than abandon his mission, Le Gentil decided to remain in India for the eight year wait until the second transit of Venus, and devote himself to the study of Indian astronomy. Finally, on the day, Venus was hidden behind clouds, and so Le Gentil saw nothing - such is life.

On his eventual return to France, having been presumed dead and stripped of his property, all his correspondence during his absence having somehow got lost, Le Gentil published a detailed account of both his travels and his astronomical studies. These were published as his Voyages dans les Mers de l'Inde, in two volumes, and is provides an invaluable account of astronomical traditions that had survived until his day in India. Curiously, many aspects of this science were no longer understood by the keepers of this knowledge, who were good enough to teach himt. As a result, much of his work was about piecing various elements together, and working out the original system. His studies influenced Bailly greatly. 


Jean-Sylvain Bailly’s Histoire de l’astronomie ancienne remains one of the most ambitious attempts to reconstruct the inheritance of ancient astronomy. Bailly drew on Greek authors, Biblical chronologies, Arabic reports, Indian tables, Chinese records, as well as the testimony of missionaries, and travellers such as Le Gentil. His aim was not to identify the underlying numerical practices that made precise astronomy possible long before the rise of modern instruments. Like Le Gentil, he looked at all the various elements available to him, and attempted to reconstruct the system they would have originally belonged to.



Sketch by Jacques-Louis David of the Tennis Court Oath. Bailly is pictured in the centre, facing the viewer, his right hand raised.
Sketch by Jacques-Louis David of the Tennis Court Oath. Bailly is pictured in the centre, facing the viewer, his right hand raised.

In Histoire de l’astronomie ancienne (1775), Bailly systematically reviewed ancient Greek, Egyptian, and Eastern sources, combining textual scholarship with the practical judgment of a working astronomer. In 1787, he followed this with a major study of Indian and Eastern astronomy, recognising its depth and antiquity at a time when such traditions were often dismissed. He treated ancient astronomy as a science, understood the immense sophistication, and time required to compute the known cycles. He took seriously the idea that very ancient cultures possessed refined astronomical knowledge.

Bailly was a brilliant scientist, who wrote about everything from Jupiter's satellites to Plato's Atlantis. He corresponded with Voltaire, received Benjamin Franklin in his home, and was a friend of Pierre-Simon Laplace. Elected as the inaugural preseident of the National Assembly in June 1789, it was he who led the famous Tennis Court proceedings, and was the first to take the oath. Among his many political triumphs were his role in passing a decree that declared Jews to be French citizens, and allieviating Paris's food shortage crisis. He became the first mayor of Paris under the Commune. However, most political careers end in failure. In such dangerous times, this all too often meant losing one's head. Deemed responsible for the massacre of the Champ de Mars in 1791, along with Lafayette, he was guillotined in 1793.


As well as his scientific acheivements, Bailly’s broader philosophical position is equally important. He insists that astronomy progresses by recognising its own limits: by knowing not absolute truth, but the boundaries within which truth must lie. Each generation refines the work of its predecessors, not by discarding them, but by tightening those bounds. The view that knowledge advances through approximation, correction, and continuity rather than rupture is especially relevant when considering monumental constructions intended to endure across centuries. Seen in this light, the numerical cycles examined in this study belong to a well-attested historical tradition. They reflect a mode of thinking that is comfortable with very long timescales, adept at switching between schematic and physical time, and capable of embedding celestial order into durable forms. Whether expressed in tables, calendars, or stone, the same astronomical system is at work.


How Old Were These Cycles?


Before looking more closely at the 60- and 600-year periods, it is worth asking how old they could be. The difficulty is that the first surviving written reference to a cycle need not come anywhere near its invention. This is particularly true of astronomy. A period such as nineteen years can only be recognised by comparing observations made over many years; a period of sixty years exceeds much of a human lifetime; and a period of 600 years, if it really was derived from observation, necessarily implies the transmission of information between generations. Of course, there's always the possibility such a period was inferred from shorter cycles. However, by the time such a cycle appears in a text, it may already be very old.


Bailly was acutely aware of this problem. He found the same astronomical numbers turning up in traditions separated by enormous distances. The nineteen-year lunisolar cycle, for example, was known in different forms among Greeks, Chaldeans, Indians, Chinese and others. The division of the Moon's path into twenty-seven or twenty-eight parts likewise appears across Asia. Alongside these observational periods were schematic numerical systems: years of 360 days, circles of 360 degrees, divisions by 60, and larger periods built from the same numbers.


China provides a particularly interesting example. Bailly recounts traditions surrounding Huangdi, conventionally placed in the third millennium BC, according to which his minister Yu-chi identified the pole star and constructed a spherical machine representing the celestial orbs. Bailly also associates the remote Chinese past with Fuxi, whom he describes as accomplished in astronomy, knowing the motions of the celestial bodies and constructing tables of them. The remembered beginning of Chinese civilisation is already populated by astronomers, celestial models and calculations.:


The 24 cardinal directions associated with the Earthly Branches and Heavenly Stems, with south (in red) placed at the top according to traditional convention. Wikimedia Commons
The 24 cardinal directions associated with the Earthly Branches and Heavenly Stems, with south (in red) placed at the top according to traditional convention. Wikimedia Commons

More important for us is the Chinese sexagenary cycle, formed by combining the ten Heavenly Stems (tiāngān) with the twelve Earthly Branches (dìzhī). These are two repeating series of signs: one runs through ten positions and the other through twelve. They advance together, first stem with first branch, second with second, and so on, until the same combination recurs after sixty steps, sixty being the lowest common multiple of ten and twelve. The result is a sequence of sixty distinct stem-and-branch combinations. Its antiquity is not in doubt.


The system is already found in the Shang oracle-bone inscriptions of the late second millennium BC, where it was used to name days; indeed, it is one of the earliest securely attested Chinese methods of recording time. The application of the same sexagenary sequence to a cycle of years is attested later, and became customary during the Han period.


Bailly regarded this Chinese cycle as part of the same sexagesimal family that he found elsewhere in ancient astronomy. Chinese tradition placed its beginnings in the age of Huangdi, the Yellow Emperor, conventionally assigned to the third millennium BC. What we can safely say is already remarkable: the ten- and twelve-part cycles were being combined into a cycle of sixty by the Shang period, more than three thousand years ago. And by the time later Chinese chronological traditions attempted to explain its beginnings, its origin had been pushed back still further, into the foundational past.


There is something particularly interesting about the arithmetic of this arrangement. The decimal and duodecimal sequences are not alternatives but are designed to operate together: because 60 is the lowest common multiple of 10 and 12, the two sequences return simultaneously to their starting positions after sixty steps. The sexagenary cycle is therefore a particularly clear example of tenfold and twelvefold structures being integrated within a single system. The twelve Earthly Branches also came to be used to divide the day into twelve periods, each equivalent to two of our modern hours, so that the same twelvefold sequence could serve as a framework for measuring daily time. Thus 12, 24 and 60 are already linked within the Chinese system, while 10 provides the second sequence required to generate the cycle of 60. This is worth bearing in mind: rather than decimal, duodecimal and sexagesimal reckoning representing competing systems, here we can actually see different numerical structures working together within a single method of organising time.

Plate from Excavations at Saqqara, 1911-12: the tomb of Hesy, by James Edward Quibell, 1913, Le Caire, Impr. de l'Institut français d'archéologie orientale, https://archive.org/details/cu31924028671299/page/n97/mode/2up
Plate from Excavations at Saqqara, 1911-12: the tomb of Hesy, by James Edward Quibell, 1913, Le Caire, Impr. de l'Institut français d'archéologie orientale, https://archive.org/details/cu31924028671299/page/n97/mode/2up

The Sexagesimal System in Metrology


The coexistence of decimal, duodecimal and sexagesimal arithmetic is not peculiar to astronomy. It is equally apparent in traditional systems of measurement. The old British system, for example, is frequently thought of as duodecimal because there are twelve inches in a foot, but it has never been exclusively based on twelve. A yard contains three feet, a rod five and a half yards, a chain four rods, a furlong ten chains, and a mile eight furlongs. The chain itself is divided into one hundred links. Thus a single continuous series of linear measures incorporates factors of 3, 4, 8, 10, 12 and 100. The same mixture appears in weights and capacities: sixteen ounces to the pound, fourteen pounds to the stone, eight stones to the hundredweight, twenty hundredweights to the ton; four gills to the pint, two pints to the quart, four quarts to the gallon and eight gallons to the bushel. These are not separate mathematical systems struggling to coexist (though to be fair there has been some chopping and changing at times). They are different operations within a practical system of measurement, in which particular numbers are chosen for their usefulness in division, multiplication and conversion.


Petrie's investigations into ancient metrology reveal similar arrangements across a much greater geographical and chronological range. In his discussion of Egyptian and Greek measures, he describes a cubit of approximately 18.23 inches, divided into twenty-five digits. Four such cubits formed an orguia of one hundred digits, while successive decimal multiplications produced larger units. He also describes a Greek foot of approximately 12.14 inches, from which an acaena of ten feet and a plethron of one hundred feet were derived. In other words, the fundamental unit might itself be divided according to one numerical scheme, while the larger measures were generated by multiplication by ten. The same principle is evident in the Assyrian measures recorded on the Senkereh tablet, where Petrie identifies a succession of units involving factors of 20, 3, 6, 2, 5, 12 and 30.


An especially intriguing example comes from the tomb of Hesy at Saqqara, dating to approximately 2650 BC. Its wall paintings include representations of measuring vessels, which Petrie studied as evidence for early Egyptian measures of capacity. As Jon Bosak explains in his subsequent analysis, the copper vessels appear to form two interleaved series, each organised through successive doubling, with proposed fundamental capacities of approximately 28.8 and 21.6 cubic inches. The numerical relationships are striking:

28.8 = 12 × 12 × 2 ÷ 10

21.6 = 6 × 6 × 6 ÷ 10

230.4 = 8 × 28.8 = 12 × 12 × 16 ÷ 10.


These relationships are particularly interesting because six, twelve and ten are not alternatives: they participate in the same arithmetic. A capacity of 28.8 cubic inches is also remarkably close to the modern United States liquid pint of 28.875 cubic inches, while eight such units give 230.4 cubic inches, close to the historical English wine gallon and the present US liquid gallon of 231 cubic inches. Jon Bosak identifies further approximate correspondences in measures associated with Persepolis and Olympia, suggesting that comparable capacities may have circulated, or been independently reproduced, over considerable distances and periods of time. (3)


This is particularly relevant to the broader question of a common mathematical language. We have already seen the ten Heavenly Stems and twelve Earthly Branches combining to produce the Chinese cycle of sixty. Egyptian, Greek and Mesopotamian metrology likewise provides examples of different numerical structures functioning together. The traditional British system, which preserves decimal multiplication alongside divisions by twelve, eight, four and other factors, reminds us that such combinations are not intrinsically contradictory. Perhaps we have been too ready to classify ancient systems according to a single numerical base, when their practical sophistication lay precisely in the ability to move between several. In the hypothetical system we are attempting to reconstruct, six might provide a fundamental family of relationships, twelve a particularly convenient means of division, sixty a larger framework for combining cycles, and ten the means of changing scale.


A Sophisticated Astronomical Tradition


There are other ways of glimpsing the depth of a sophisticated astronomical tradition in various parts of the world. One of the most beautiful involves the Pleiades. These stars are particularly useful to an ancient observer because they are bright, distinctive and easy to recognise, while their rising and setting shift slowly in relation to the seasons because of precession. They consequently became markers of the year across an extraordinary geographical range. Hesiod used their rising to announce harvest and their setting to announce ploughing. In India they became Kṛttikā, associated with the system of twenty-seven or twenty-eight lunar nakṣatras. In Mesopotamia they were MUL.MUL, “the Stars”, and appear in calendrical rules concerned with the regulation of the year. In China they formed the lunar mansion Mao. Other peoples used their heliacal appearance to mark seasons or the beginning of a year.


Bailly was fascinated by something more specific. Ancient traditions appeared to remember a time when the Pleiades occupied a significant position in relation to the equinox. Al-Bīrūnī, writing in the eleventh century, referred to books attributed to Hermes which placed the equinox among the Pleiades, and understood this as evidence of a very remote epoch. In the seventeenth century, a genius Jesuit priest, Denis Pétau, had already attempted a similar reconstruction from ancient descriptions of their rising and setting and arrived at dates in the third millennium BC. The precise dates depend on particular interpetations of the texts. Ancient astronomical traditions preserved configurations of the sky that later astronomers believed belonged to a much earlier age.


The Pleiades therefore give us a useful glimpse of what astronomical knowledge looked like long ago. A small cluster of stars could serve simultaneously as a seasonal marker, a lunar station and a regulator of the calendar. Its behaviour could be watched from one generation to the next, and because the sky itself changes slowly, traditions concerning it could preserve traces of much earlier observations.


This is important when we come to periods such as 60 and 600 years. These numbers belong to a very long process of watching, counting and comparing. It must have taken many many geenrations to discover the now familiar nineteen-year cycle, which is almost exactly 235 lunar months. First the phases of the Moon and the return of the seasons have to be recorded accurately; then observations made years apart have to be compared; then somebody has to recognise that the two cycles, although individually incommensurable, approach one another again after nineteen years. Longer periods require longer records, or the inheritance of records made by earlier observers. A 600-year period is a good example: if the period was genuinely astronomical rather than simply generated mathematically, its discovery presupposes either records extending over many generations or sufficiently advanced mathematics to derive the longer period from shorter, already well-established cycles.


That is why it is misleading to speak of ancient astronomy of the classical period, for example in Greece or Babylon, as a science in its infancy. By the time of the oldest known texts, we find calendars being corrected by intercalation, the Moon's path divided into stations, long lunisolar cycles being used to reconcile incompatible celestial motions, and sexagesimal periods embedded in chronology. What survives looks less like a first attempt to understand the heavens than the result of a very long habit of observation. This was essentially Bailly's point. As an astronomer himself, he understood the difficulty of even defining a tropical or sidereal year to within a few minutes. Yet, he found values for these in the tables discovered by Le Gentil, and beyond. When he compared the astronomical traditions of India, China and Chaldea, he was struck not simply by what they knew but by the strange unevenness of that knowledge. Highly accurate methods could survive alongside much cruder ones; calculations were sometimes performed without any apparent understanding of why they worked; old observations were preserved after their original purpose had been forgotten. To Bailly, these did not look like the beginnings of a science. They looked like its remnants, the débris of an older astronomical tradition whose original structure had been partly lost. The ancient sources give us cycles whose origins they often do not explain, spread across cultures which sometimes preserve strikingly similar ways of dividing and measuring celestial motion. And amongst those numbers, one keeps returning: 60. There are 60-year cycles, 600-year cycles and periods of 3 600 years. The circle contains 360 degrees. Time itself came to be divided sexagesimally. If these really are fragments of a common mathematical language, then perhaps the place to begin reconstructing it is with the most mysterious of these ancient periods: the Great Year of 600 years.


Bailly found a similar clue in another conspicuous star, Aldebaran, and here his argument becomes particularly relevant to the question of dating. Discussing the ancient Persian division of the zodiac, he drew attention to four exceptionally bright stars which, in his reconstruction, had once marked the four cardinal points of the solar year: Aldebaran at the spring equinox, Antares at the autumn equinox, Regulus at the summer solstice and Fomalhaut at the winter solstice. The four stars, he observed, formed an approximate division of the heavens into four equal parts. Calculating backwards for the effect of precession, he placed this configuration around 3000 BC:

“Consequently we observe that, around the year 3000 BC, the stars having advanced by 60°, Aldebaran was precisely at the spring equinox.”

Bailly was quite explicit about what followed and what did not. The astronomical configuration suggested great antiquity, but the attribution of a particular cultural meaning to it was an inference. Nevertheless, having arrived at approximately 3000 BC through his discussion of the Persian zodiac, he immediately turned to the Indian material brought back by Le Gentil. Here he encountered a remarkably close date. The astronomical system of the Brahmins used the Kali Yuga epoch, which Bailly placed at 3102 BC. He regarded this as a genuine chronological epoch, writing:

“We have said that the Kali Yuga epoch of the Brahmins, which appears to be a genuine chronological epoch, goes back to the year 3102.”

This does not, of course, mean that all the tables recorded by Le Gentil can simply be dated to 3102 BC. Le Gentil encountered a living astronomical tradition in eighteenth-century India, transmitted to him by Brahmins, and the date at which the particular tables he recorded were first compiled is not known. But in some ways, the data pointed to 3102 BC as a chronological and astronomical framework. Bailly's account becomes even more interesting when he describes the Indian distinction between two zodiacs. One was tied to the stars, while the other was related to the moving equinoctial framework. Because a cycle called axial precession gradually sees the equinox move, relative to the fixed stars, the two zodiacs slowly separate. Le Gentil reports that the Indian system assigned this motion a complete revolution of 24 000 years. At 54 seconds of arc per year, the value given to him by the Brahmins, the arithmetic is exact:

360° = 1 296 000″

1 296 000″ ÷ 54″ = 24 000 years.

However, the cycle of axial precession is closer to 26 000 years, and the difference between 24 000 and this seems an odd mistake. Was the 24 000 year cycle rather an extension of the 600-year cycle at work?


Bailly also records a much larger chronological construction. According to his account, the two zodiacs had originally coincided 10 400 years before the beginning of the Kali Yuga, and, given the Indian period of 24 000 years for the revolution of the stars, would coincide again in year 3600 of the Kali Yuga, corresponding in his chronology to AD 499:

“These two zodiacs began together 10,400 years before the Kali Yuga epoch; but since the revolution of the stars is, according to the Indians, 24,000 years, the two zodiacs must have come together again in the year 3600 of that epoch, corresponding to AD 499.”

The 10 400 years are particularly striking arithmetically. If the Kali Yuga epoch is placed at 3102 BC, Bailly's scheme pushes the preceding coincidence of the two zodiacs back to approximately 13 500 BC. Adding 10 400 years before the Kali epoch and 3 600 years after it gives 14 000 years between the two stated coincidences; the remaining 10 000 years complete the Indian 24 000-year stellar revolution. Whether this scheme represents historical observations made at those remote dates is an entirely separate question. What

Bailly is reporting is the chronological architecture of the system as he understood it.

He then asks an obvious question: why should AD 499 have been chosen as the point at which the revolution of the fixed stars began again? His answer takes him back once more to Aldebaran and the Kali Yuga epoch. He calculates that in 3102 BC Aldebaran would have stood in the twenty-ninth degree of Pisces, only about one degree from the spring equinox:

“In the year 3102, Aldebaran was in the 29th degree of Pisces; it lacked only one degree to be at the equinox. They would have established the beginning of their zodiac at this star.”

Bailly also places the Pleiades in the eighteenth degree of Pisces at this epoch and remarks upon their heliacal rising in connection with the return of spring. We therefore return to the same kind of evidence encountered above: conspicuous stars, seasonal markers and the slow displacement produced by precession.


It is important to distinguish Bailly's evidence from his interpretation of it. His own language makes the speculative stages perfectly visible: “they would have established”, “they would therefore have concluded”, “it appears clear to us”. He was reconstructing a lost history from surviving astronomical structures. But the numerical framework he was trying to explain is clear enough. His Indian material connected an epoch of 3102 BC with a precessional motion of 54″ per year, a complete stellar revolution of 24 000 years, and a distinction between fixed and moving celestial reference systems. His separate discussion of the Persian zodiac led him, through the positions of Aldebaran and the other cardinal stars, to an epoch of approximately 3000 BC. The proximity of these dates was one of the reasons he believed that the traditions contained memories of a much older astronomy.

For our purposes, it is not necessary to accept Bailly's historical reconstruction in order to recognise the importance of what he was trying to explain. The eighteenth-century tables themselves cannot be dated merely from their epoch, but neither was their remote chronology simply an invention of Bailly's. He was confronted with an astronomical system whose internal reckoning extended thousands of years into the past, and he attempted to test that chronology against the changing positions of the stars.




A Period of 600 Years


Of all the ancient periods Bailly discusses, one particularly fascinated him: this “Great Year” of 600 years. His starting point was an intriguing passage in Josephus, who claimed that the patriarchs before the Flood had lived for such extraordinary lengths of time partly because this allowed them to perfect geometry and astronomy. Six hundred years were necessary, he explained, because it was only after the revolution of six centuries that the “Great Year” was completed. Bailly took the story seriously, not necessarily because of the fabulous lifespans, but because the number itself appeared to preserve a genuine astronomical period. He also noted that Josephus cited earlier authorities, including Manetho, Hecataeus and Berossus, and took this to mean that the tradition of a 600-year Great Year was considerably older than Josephus himself.

The astronomer Giovanni Domenico Cassini had already noticed something remarkable about it. If the Great Year was astronomical, he reasoned, it ought to bring different celestial revolutions back into agreement. And 600 years does exactly that for the Sun and Moon with surprising accuracy.

Cassini calculated that 7 421 lunar months of 29 days, 12 hours, 44 minutes and 3 seconds amounted to approximately 219 146½ days. The same interval could be expressed as 600 solar years of 365 days, 5 hours, 51 minutes and 36 seconds. Bailly was deeply impressed by this, remarking that the resulting year differed by only a few minutes from the value known in his own day.

Using modern mean values changes the figures slightly but leaves the underlying relationship intact. Six hundred tropical years contain 219 145.32 days; divided by the mean synodic month of 29.53059 days, this gives 7 420.9597 lunations. In other words, 600 solar years fall only about 1.19 days short of 7 421 complete lunar months.

The importance of the 600-year period goes even further than the correspondence between solar years and lunar phases. Using modern mean values, 600 tropical years fall within about 1.72 days of 8 021 sidereal months, and about 3.98 days of 7 953 anomalistic months. Three different lunar clocks, the Moon relative to the Sun, to the stars, and to its own apsidal cycle, therefore approach whole numbers within the same six-century period. The draconic month, measured relative to the lunar nodes, does not fit 600 years nearly so closely, but at ten times the period something extraordinary happens: 6 000 tropical years come within about 0.31 days of 80 532 draconic months. In that sense the 600 / 6 000-year framework begins to resemble, on a much larger scale, a combination of the principles embodied by the Metonic cycle and the Saros: not simply a return of lunar phase, but a means of bringing several different lunar motions into a common system of reckoning.

Perhaps the purpose of the long period was not to make one celestial clock return perfectly, but to provide a common grid on which several imperfectly commensurable clocks could be compared. Six may have become sacred because it worked extraordinarily well.

Six has exceptional mathematical properties even before astronomy enters the picture. It is the first perfect number:

1 + 2 + 3 = 6

and also

1 x 2 x 3 = 6

It sits at the meeting point of 2 and 3, the first even and first odd prime:

2 x 3 = 6

From it an extraordinarily productive numerical architecture can be generated:

6 x 10 = 60

6 x 60 = 360

6 x 100 = 600

60^2 = 3600

600 x 360 = 216 000 = 60^3

These beautifully structured numbers aren't merely mathematically convenient. Some of them also land unexpectedly close to real celestial recurrences. Nature gives you a messy collection of incommensurable periods, such as the tropical year, the synodic month, the sidereal month, the anomalistic month, and the draconic month. Yet a number generated naturally from this six-based family, 600, comes remarkably close to reconciling several of them. What is the origin of a “sacred number”? It could originally mean something closer to a number perceived to reveal the mathematical order underlying nature. That would make the subsequent symbolism the result of mathematical astronomy rather than its cause. And historically, of course, six really does acquire exceptional status in later mathematical and philosophical traditions. The Pythagorean tradition's interest in perfect numbers, and later writers' theological interpretations of 6 as perfect, show that this way of thinking certainly existed. Perhaps 6, or 600, is Plato's perfect number of time. What we cannot establish from the numerical evidence alone is how far back that interpretation goes.  If astronomers then discovered that periods constructed from this numerical family also brought several otherwise incommensurable celestial motions into remarkably close agreement, six may have seemed to possess something more than computational convenience. Its later symbolic or sacred status could conceivably preserve a recognition that this number appeared to belong to the architecture of the heavens themselves. Could it be the origin of the idea of dividing up circles, of time and space, by 6 and multipels of 6?



That is impressive enough. But what interested Bailly almost as much as the accuracy of the period was the question of how anyone could have discovered it.

He saw two possibilities. Either the period had emerged from observations continued over an extraordinarily long time, or it had been calculated by astronomers who already possessed sufficiently accurate values for the movements of the Sun and Moon. This would be possible in theory from close observation of the Metonic cycle. Bailly imagined generations of observers recording new and full moons, preserving their observations and comparing them with much older ones. After centuries, they might discover that the Moon returned not merely to approximately the same date, but almost to the same hour. Alternatively, once astronomy had become sufficiently developed, the 600-year period could have been found mathematically from shorter known periods.

Either possibility interested him, because neither makes 600 years a primitive discovery. A cycle of that length presupposes a tradition behind it.

But 600 did not stand alone. This is where the story becomes much more interesting.

Bailly repeatedly places it within a family of periods based upon 60. He found a 60-year period in Indian chronology and in the traditions of China and Babylon. He also found a period of 3 600 years in Indian astronomical calculations, and regarded it as six periods of 600 years. As he put it, the Indians did not explicitly know the ancient 600-year period, but “they make use of it without knowing it”: their 3 600-year period contained six of them.

The same sequence appeared in accounts of Chaldean astronomy. In the terminology Bailly inherited from the ancient sources, the sossos was a period of 60 years, ten sossoi formed a neros of 600 years, and six neroi formed a saros of 3,600 years. Bailly recognised the resemblance to the periods he had found in India.

This ancient use of the word saros might be a bit confusing, because it is not the Saros we mean today. We now use the name for the familiar eclipse cycle of 223 lunar months, or a little over eighteen years, thanks to Edmund Halley. Bailly and Le Gentil were discussing a much older use of the term for a period of 3 600 years. The confusion itself is revealing: ancient names, numbers and periods had survived through different authors long after their original meanings had become uncertain.

So these periods were all linked: 60 years, 600 years, 3 600 years. And this was precisely the pattern that caught Le Gentil's attention when he encountered related periods in Indian astronomy.

Le Gentil was not content simply to catalogue them. He wanted to know what they were for. At first the obvious answer was lunisolar reconciliation. Sixty years gives a rough relationship between solar years and lunar months; 600 years gives a much better one; 3 600 years extends the system still further. It's easy to imagine the larger periods developing as accumulated errors in shorter periods became apparent. But Le Gentil eventually became dissatisfied with that explanation. He realised that periods of 60, 600 and 3 600 years could not be understood simply as intervals after which new moons, full moons or eclipses returned on a fixed date. He therefore wrote:

“These periods of 600 and 3 600 years, and even of 60 years, must therefore be considered from another point of view than that of bringing back the conjunctions of the Moon with the Sun, or eclipses, after a fixed and determined interval.”

The “other point of view” he proposed was the Moon's apogee, and therefore the anomalistic motion of the Moon.


The Anomalistic Month


What's the anomalistic month? The synodic month measures the return from one new Moon to the next, but it is not the Moon's only cycle. Because the lunar orbit is elliptical, the Moon also moves between perigee and apogee, completing an anomalistic revolution in about 27.55455 days. Its distance and apparent speed therefore change continually, something that matters enormously when attempting accurate calculations of its position and of eclipses.

Le Gentil had encountered an Indian lunar table based upon a period of 248 days, after which, he tells us, the Brahmins supposed the Moon to return to the same point in its cycle. The number seems rather arbitrary until it is compared with the anomalistic month. Nine anomalistic months amount to 247.99095 days, less than thirteen minutes short of 248 days.

For Le Gentil, relationships of this sort suggested that the great periods were connected with a much deeper knowledge of lunar theory. He eventually concluded:

“These periods of 600 years have an evident relationship with the Moon's apogee, which proves that the Ancients had made a fairly profound study of the theory of this celestial body.”

That is quite a statement. Le Gentil was not presenting 600 years as a curious piece of ancient chronology. He thought it belonged to a system capable of tracking one of the subtler irregularities in the Moon's motion. He could see it was a key part of the numbers in the tables he was allowed to study, during his time in India.

And this is where Bailly and Le Gentil become particularly useful guides. They were both confronted by the same problem. The periods were clearly old. They appeared in more than one ancient tradition. They seemed to belong together. Yet their original purpose was no longer obvious.

There was another aspect of the anomalistic month that began to seem important to me. It did not merely measure another kind of lunar return. It measured an irregularity. The Moon does not travel across the sky at a constant speed, because its distance from the Earth changes through its orbit. Le Gentil's 248-day table was therefore a way of modelling variation within a cycle.


The Moon and its Moving Point of Return


There is something rather surprising about Le Gentil's investigation of the ancient Indian lunar periods. We might expect the fundamental concern of an early astronomical system to have been the phases of the Moon, and particularly the reconciliation of the lunar and solar years. This is, after all, the problem addressed by the familiar Metonic cycle, in which 235 synodic months correspond approximately to nineteen solar years. But Le Gentil discovered that the Indian periods he was examining appeared to be organised around something quite different: the anomalistic revolution of the Moon, its return to the apogee or perigee of its orbit.

The distinction is important. The synodic month measures the return of the Moon to the same phase in relation to the Sun. The anomalistic month measures its return to the same position relative to the apsides of its orbit, the line joining its nearest and farthest points from the Earth. The Moon does not travel around the Earth at a uniform speed. It moves more rapidly when nearer the Earth, at perigee, and more slowly when farther away, at apogee. Moreover, the line of apsides itself moves, so that the anomalistic month, approximately 27.55455 days, is not the same as the sidereal month of approximately 27.32166 days. We are dealing, therefore, not simply with the Moon's return to a position, but with the changing geometry of its orbit.

Le Gentil was particularly struck by the Indian period of 248 days, which corresponds remarkably closely to nine anomalistic months. The Brahmins possessed a table giving the Moon's daily movement throughout this period, and the movements were not uniform. They increased and diminished in a regular sequence, reflecting the Moon's changing speed. Le Gentil observed that the table bore a striking resemblance to the predictions of the simple elliptical hypothesis used by European astronomers. He even remarked that the apparent diameters of the Moon derived from the Indian calculations agreed reasonably well with those obtained from the tables of Cassini and Halley. This was not merely a calendar of lunar phases, but a numerical representation of the Moon's changing motion.

The period of 248 days was also part of a larger computational structure. Le Gentil recorded periods of 3 031 and 12,372 days, corresponding approximately to 110 and 449 anomalistic revolutions respectively. The relationship between them is particularly elegant: 12 372 is exactly four times 3 031 plus 248, just as 449 is four times 110 plus nine. The same mathematical relationship appears in the numbers of days and in the corresponding revolutions of the Moon. What emerges is not a collection of unrelated astronomical numbers, but a coherent arrangement of increasingly long approximations to the same celestial motion.

It was this observation that led Le Gentil to reconsider the much larger periods of 60, 600 and 3 600 years. He recognised that the 600-year period was not an exact reconciliation of the lunar phases with the solar year. Indeed, using the solar year attributed to the Brahmins, he calculated a discrepancy of approximately seven hours, which would accumulate over longer periods. Why, then, should such periods have been preserved? His answer was that their purpose might not have been to restore the Moon to conjunction with the Sun at all. Instead, he proposed that they should be understood in relation to the Moon's apogee. In his words, « Ce point de vue m'a paru être évidemment celui de considérer la Lune par rapport à son apogée, c'est ce que nous appelons la révolution anomalistique de la Lune. »

There is a revealing simplicity to his demonstration. Taking a period of 1 296 days, Le Gentil divided it by 248 and obtained a remainder of 56. Looking up the fifty-sixth day in the Indian lunar table, he found the Moon at its minimum daily movement, which he identified with its passage through apogee. A simple division and its remainder thus located a particular condition of the Moon's orbit. The longer numerical period had been brought back to the shorter observational table.

This raises a question about the choice of fundamental astronomical periods. The Metonic cycle is an extraordinarily useful reconciliation of solar years and lunar phases, and nineteen years became important in several calendrical traditions. But nineteen does not, by itself, describe the Moon's varying orbital speed or the movement of its apsides. The periods examined by Le Gentil address a different problem. They suggest an interest not merely in when the Moon will return to the same phase, but in how it moves between successive returns. And the larger numerical family of 60, 600 and 3 600 years belongs to a system with far greater possibilities for division, multiplication and comparison with other astronomical periods.

This distinction is very suggestive. Perhaps the purpose of a great astronomical period was never simply to bring the Sun and Moon back into agreement. Perhaps it was to provide a common numerical framework in which several different celestial movements could be calculated, compared and corrected. The phases of the Moon, its position among the stars, its distance from the Earth and its relationship to the nodes of its orbit are all different measures of lunar time. The elegance of the system lies not in making these movements identical, but in finding numerical relationships between them. What Le Gentil recognised in the Indian tables was a mathematics capable of preserving the irregularities of the heavens within a regular framework.


Dividing by Sixty


The Sun presents an analogous problem. A schematic year can be divided perfectly into twelve sectors of thirty degrees, but the apparent Sun does not spend exactly the same amount of time traversing each sector. The mathematical circle is uniform; celestial motion is not. Perhaps this was precisely the point of the system: not to pretend that the heavens moved uniformly, but to provide a uniform grid against which their irregularities could be calculated.

Bailly approached the problem principally through the sexagesimal system. Sixty, he observed, has many divisors and is exceptionally convenient for calculation. He believed this explained not only the 60-year period but a much wider family of ancient practices: the division of the circle into 360 degrees, the sexagesimal subdivision of time and angle, periods of 60 days and 60 years, and larger periods constructed by continuing the same numerical progression. The fact that these practices appeared so widely convinced him that they had a common origin.

Le Gentil approached the same numbers from the other direction. He was looking at the actual machinery of astronomical calculation and asking what celestial movements these periods might encode. His interest in the Moon's apogee is particularly revealing because it moves us beyond the simple idea that ancient astronomers were merely trying to keep a lunar calendar aligned with the seasons.

Taken together, their investigations leave us with an intriguing possibility. Sixty may be the mathematical framework, while 600 is one of the places where that framework locks unusually well onto the actual sky. Six hundred is ten times 60, but it is also very close to 7 421 synodic months. The larger period of 3 600 years is 60 squared and six times 600. The numbers are mathematically related before we even ask what astronomical functions they perform.

This may also help explain why such periods could survive after their purpose had been forgotten. A useful numerical framework can be applied to more than one celestial problem. A 60-year period need not have been invented for one single phenomenon, nor must 600 years have served only as a lunisolar cycle. The same numerical architecture could accommodate the Sun and Moon, lunar anomaly, planetary movements and progressively larger cycles. Different cultures might therefore preserve different pieces of the same system.

That possibility becomes particularly interesting when we turn to the enormous periods of Indian chronology. The Yugas are built from numbers such as 432 000, 864 000, 1 296 000 and 1 728 000 years. At first sight these seem to belong to an entirely different world: cosmology rather than practical astronomy. But they are saturated with the same numerical vocabulary, multiples of 6, 12, 36, 60, 72 and 432. If the smaller periods of 60, 600 and 3,600 can be shown to have genuine astronomical functions, it becomes reasonable to ask whether the enormous numbers of the Yugas are really disconnected from them, or whether they preserve the expansion of the same system onto a much larger scale.

Before going that far, however, there is a more immediate question to answer. Why 600?


The period of 600 years was remembered as a Great Year. Cassini found an extraordinarily good lunisolar relationship within it. And Bailly placed it within a widespread sexagesimal family of 60, 600 and 3 600 years. Le Gentil suspected these same periods had another astronomical function connected with the anomalistic motion of the Moon. So rather than assuming that 600 was chosen for one reason, can we find other astronomical relationships converge upon it, and whether they begin to reveal the structure of the larger system to which Bailly and Le Gentil suspected it once belonged?



How Astronomical Cycles Work


Before trying to work out what the 600-year period was actually for, it is worth looking more closely at what an astronomical cycle does. The basic problem is very simple. The Sun and Moon do not keep time in convenient whole numbers. The synodic month, which is the interval from one new Moon to the next, is about 29.53059 days. The tropical year is about 365.2422 days. Twelve lunar months therefore give only about 354.37 days, while thirteen give about 383.90. Neither fits the solar year.

For anyone trying to construct a calendar from both Sun and Moon, this is an unavoidable problem. The two clocks are continually slipping past one another.

The solution is to stop looking for an exact relationship within a single year and ask when the two clocks will come close to meeting again. The best-known ancient example is the 19-year Metonic cycle. Nineteen tropical years contain almost exactly 235 synodic months:

19 × 365.2422 ≈ 6 939.60 days.

The difference is only about two hours. After nineteen years, therefore, the phases of the Moon return to almost the same dates in the solar year.

This is the essential principle behind the great astronomical cycles. Two movements which refuse to fit together over a short interval may come extraordinarily close to doing so over a longer one. The trick is to find the right pair of whole numbers.

But the Moon alone has several different periods, depending upon what exactly we choose to measure. Its phases repeat according to the synodic month. It returns to approximately the same place among the stars according to the sidereal month. It returns to the same node of its orbit according to the draconic month, important for eclipses. And it returns to perigee or apogee according to the anomalistic month, which affects its distance, apparent size and speed. This is why different ancient cycles solve different problems.

The modern Saros, for example, is not simply a Sun-Moon calendar cycle. Its 223 synodic months are also very close to whole numbers of draconic and anomalistic months. The Moon therefore returns not only to almost the same phase, but close to the same node and the same part of its elliptical orbit. That is why similar eclipses recur after a Saros.

The Metonic cycle does something different. Nineteen solar years correspond closely to 235 synodic months, but also to approximately 254 sidereal months. So one cycle can express several relationships at once. A particularly useful period may have survived precisely because several celestial clocks come unusually close to agreement within it.


The eight-year cycle gives an even more intuitive example. Eight tropical years are about 2 921.94 days. Ninety-nine synodic months are about 2 923.53 days: not an exact match, but close. At the same time, five synodic periods of Venus amount to roughly 2 919.6 days. After eight years, then, the Sun, Moon and Venus have all completed numbers of their own cycles that bring them back surprisingly close to their earlier relationships.

This helps explain why ancient astronomy accumulated periods of different lengths. There was no single perfect cycle because there was no single celestial clock. A period might be chosen because it reconciled Sun and Moon particularly well; another because it incorporated Venus; another because it brought the Moon back to its node or apogee; another because it fitted conveniently into a calendar. Longer periods could combine or correct shorter ones.

Back panel of a recreation of the Antikythera Mechanism, showing the Saros and Metonic cycles. Tony Freeth - Original publication: The Antikythera Mechanism Research Project Immediate The Antikythera Mechanism Research Project
Back panel of a recreation of the Antikythera Mechanism, showing the Saros and Metonic cycles. Tony Freeth - Original publication: The Antikythera Mechanism Research Project Immediate The Antikythera Mechanism Research Project

The Antikythera mechanism gives us a wonderful surviving example of this way of thinking. Its back dials incorporated the nineteen-year Metonic cycle and the 223-month Saros, together with longer periods such as the seventy-six-year Callippic cycle and the fifty-four-year Exeligmos. These were not simply separate facts about the heavens. They were connected mechanically through ratios of gears. One celestial movement could, quite literally, be translated into another through number.

This is perhaps the easiest way to understand ancient astronomical cycles. They are translations between clocks. Sometimes the clock itself is artificial. The Egyptians, for example, used a civil year of exactly 365 days. Twenty-five such years contain 9 125 days, remarkably close to 309 synodic lunar months. This provided a manageable lunar cycle within the civil calendar. But the 365-day civil year itself slowly slipped against the actual solar year. If we compare it with a schematic year of 365¼ days, the difference accumulates at exactly one day every four years. After 1 461 civil years, the two counts coincide again:

1 461 × 365 = 1 460 × 365.25 = 533 265 days.

The famous Sothic cycle is therefore another example of the same principle on a much larger scale: allow two clocks to drift, calculate the rate of the drift, and find the point at which they meet again.

This also explains something that can otherwise look rather odd in ancient astronomy: the simultaneous use of several different kinds of “year”. A year might contain 365 days for civil purposes, 365¼ for one kind of long-term calculation, approximately 365.2422 days when measuring the tropical return of the seasons, or approximately 365.256 days when measuring the Earth's return relative to the stars. None of these has to mean that an astronomer was confused about the length of the year. They are different measures for different purposes.

And then there is 360. This number requires particular attention, because it belongs to a slightly different category. A year of 360 days is obviously not an accurate measurement of the solar year. Ancient astronomers were perfectly capable of knowing this. The Egyptian calendar itself makes the point rather neatly: twelve months of thirty days produce 360, after which five additional days have to be added to complete the 365-day civil year.

So why retain 360 at all?

A circle contains 360 degrees. A schematic year of 360 units therefore allows time and angular movement to be placed on the same numerical grid: one complete revolution corresponds to 360 units, and an average movement of one unit per day corresponds to one degree around the circle. The correspondence does not have to describe the physical year exactly to be computationally useful. This distinction is crucial. An observed astronomical period and the numerical grid used to calculate it are not necessarily the same thing.

The tropical year of 365.2422 days belongs to the sky. So does the synodic month of 29.53059 days. They are quantities we discover by observation. But 60 and 360 can function differently. They provide a framework within which awkward natural periods can be divided, compared and recombined. Why was a 360-unit revolution so useful that the same numerical structure could be applied to time, angle and astronomical cycles?

As a straightforward lunisolar period, it is already impressive. Six hundred tropical years contain almost exactly 7 421 synodic months: But that calculation uses the observed tropical year of 365.2422 days. What happens if 600 is also examined within the computational framework of 360? Then something quite different appears:

600 × 360 = 216 000 = 60³.

That changes the nature of the question. Six hundred may be interesting because it produces an excellent reconciliation of the actual Sun and Moon. But within a 360-unit framework it also produces the perfect sexagesimal cube. So we are looking at two things at once: a number belonging to the mathematical grid, and an astronomical period that fits the real sky remarkably well.



Taking Apart the 600-Year Cycle


In the real sky, 600 tropical years come remarkably close to 7 421 synodic months. But in the schematic system of 360 units, 600 years become 216 000 days, or exactly 60³. One relationship comes from the observed movements of the Sun and Moon; the other comes from the internal architecture of the sexagesimal system. This period of time that reconciles sun and moon so well seems to have been used then as a mathematical tool itself.

Le Gentil had already followed the problem some way in this direction. He knew that the 600-year period gave a good lunisolar relationship, but he was not satisfied that this explained why periods of 60, 600 and 3 600 years had been preserved. If their only purpose was to bring lunar phases back into agreement with the solar year, there were shorter and more practical ways of doing it. The nineteen-year cycle, after all, does this extremely well.

So he began looking elsewhere.

“These periods of 600 and 3 600 years, and even of 60 years, must therefore be considered from another point of view than that of bringing back the conjunctions of the Moon with the Sun, or eclipses, after a fixed and determined interval.”

The clue came from another rather peculiar number in the Indian astronomical calculations he was studying: 248. Le Gentil describes a table which followed the changing daily motion of the Moon through a period of 248 days, after which the calculation began again.

Nine anomalistic months give 9 × 27.55455 = 247.99095 days. That is only 0.00905 days short of 248: a difference of about thirteen minutes. So 248 is a very different kind of number from 60 or 360. There is no obvious reason to choose it because it is mathematically convenient. Its usefulness appears to arise from the behaviour of the Moon itself.

And this is where Le Gentil's calculations become fascinating. He compared this 248-day lunar period with the apparently quite different periods of 60 and 600 years, using the schematic year of 360 days. Dividing these 21 600 days by 248, we obtain 87 complete periods, with 24 days left over: 21 600 = 87 × 248 + 24.

Extending the same system to 600 years and something more striking happens:

600 × 360 = 216 000 days.

This contains 870 complete periods of 248 days, with 240 days remaining:

216 000 = 870 × 248 + 240.

But 240 is only eight days short of another complete 248-day period. In other words:

871 × 248 = 216 008.

So 600 schematic years and 871 periods of 248 days differ by only eight days in 216 000.

This was enough for Le Gentil to conclude that the 600-year periods had an “evident relationship with the Moon's apogee”, which in his view showed that the ancients had made “a fairly profound study of the theory of this celestial body”.

There is an important distinction here. We are not dealing with 600 actual tropical years. We have deliberately changed systems. Six hundred tropical years amount to about 219 145 days and give the extraordinary correspondence with 7 421 synodic months. Le Gentil's calculation uses 600 × 360 = 216 000 ideal units. And that is precisely what makes it interesting.

The same number, 600, is operating on both sides of the divide. Applied to the observed tropical year, it gives an excellent approximation to a whole number of lunar phases. Applied to the schematic 360-unit revolution, it gives a very close approximation to a whole number of 248-day anomalistic periods. So perhaps the 360-year calculation should not be thought of as an inferior version of the 365.2422-year calculation at all. It is doing something different. This suggests a useful distinction. Some numbers belong to the sky; others belong to the grid.

Bailly himself provides an illuminating explanation of what such a 360-day year could mean. Discussing Indian astronomy, he insists that the Indians did not mistake 360 days for the actual length of the year. Their lunar year was divided computationally into 360 “fictitious days”, and a similar procedure was applied to the Sun: its annual revolution was represented by supposing the Sun to move through one degree per day, so that the 360 degrees of the circle became a hypothetical year of 360 days. Bailly stresses that this was a supposition convenient for calculation, from which Indian astronomers possessed methods of reduction back to the real celestial movements. The 360-day year, in other words, belonged to the mathematical model rather than being an erroneous observation of nature.

This distinction is important. If the actual tropical year of 365.2422 days is mapped continuously onto 360 equal divisions, each ideal division corresponds to approximately 1.0145617 ordinary days. But in Le Gentil's calculation the 360 divisions are being used as schematic day-counting units. It is at this computational level that 871 x 248 = 216 008, producing the remarkable difference of only eight units. We should therefore resist treating the 216 000 as though it were simply another expression for the 219 145.32 actual days in 600 tropical years. It belongs to the grid.

In the observed heavens, 600 tropical years give an exceptionally close approximation to 7 421 synodic months. In the schematic system, 600 ideal years give 216 000 = 60 x 60 x 60 units and come within eight of 871 x 248. The same number, 600, therefore operates on both sides of the divide: once in observation and once in computation. Some numbers belong to the sky; others belong to the grid, and the astronomical system provides the means of translating between them.



Bailly himself was quite explicit that a long astronomical period could not simply be translated into a calendar by counting identical years indefinitely. The discrepancy had to be managed through intercalation. Discussing the 600-year period, he attempted to reconstruct precisely such a system:


Cette période, cette longueur exacte de l’année de 365 jours, 5 heures, 51 minutes, 36 secondes, exigeait des intercalations. L’année était sans doute de douze mois de trente jours, avec cinq jours ajoutés à la fin du dernier mois, suivant l’usage de plusieurs nations, usage qui paraît avoir été général dans l’Orient. Mais 600 ans de 365 jours ne font que 219 000 jours ; la période en contient 219 146 : il y en avait donc 146 intercalés d’une manière quelconque.L’intercalation la plus naturelle, et celle qui fut certainement pratiquée, est l’intercalation d’un jour tous les quatre ans, celle qui subsiste encore dans notre année bissextile. Elle est de la plus haute antiquité à la Chine ; elle est connue des Indiens ; on en trouve des traces jusqu’en Égypte. Nous ne nous lassons point de répéter que les mêmes méthodes pratiquées chez différents peuples doivent avoir une source commune ; et comme nous avons ici besoin d’une intercalation, il est naturel de supposer celle que l’on retrouve chez ces différents peuples. En lisant la suite de cet ouvrage, on se convaincra que l’astronomie de ces premiers temps est la source commune où les anciens peuples ont puisé, ou plutôt d’où étaient sorties la plupart de leurs connaissances.L’intercalation d’un jour tous les quatre ans, au bout de 600 années, aurait fait 150 jours ; comme il n’en fallait que 146, il y a apparence que tous les 150 ans on supprimait un jour intercalaire, ou, s’il est permis d’user de ce mot, une année bissextile, comme nous faisons aujourd’hui tous les 100 ans. Ces 150 ans devenaient une espèce de période dont nous pourrons retrouver quelques traces ailleurs.

Translated as:

This period, this exact length of the year of 365 days, 5 hours, 51 minutes and 36 seconds, required intercalations. The year was undoubtedly composed of twelve months of thirty days, with five days added at the end of the final month, following the practice of several nations, a practice which appears to have been general in the East. But 600 years of 365 days amount to only 219,000 days, while the period contains 219,146; there must therefore have been 146 days intercalated in some manner.The most natural intercalation, and the one which was certainly practised, is the intercalation of one day every four years, which still survives in our leap year. It is of the highest antiquity in China; it is known to the Indians; traces of it are found even in Egypt. We never tire of repeating that the same methods practised among different peoples must have a common source; and since we require an intercalation here, it is natural to suppose the use of the one which is found among these different peoples. In reading the remainder of this work, one will become convinced that the astronomy of these earliest times is the common source from which the ancient peoples drew, or rather from which most of their knowledge had emerged.The intercalation of one day every four years would, after 600 years, have produced 150 days; since only 146 were required, it appears that every 150 years an intercalary day was suppressed — or, if I may use the expression, a leap year — just as we now do every 100 years. These 150 years thus became a kind of period, traces of which we may be able to find elsewhere. (2)

An ordinary four-year intercalation would insert 150 days, but only 146 are needed, so he proposes suppressing four of them, one every150 years



What, then, is the 60-year period?


This also changes the way we can approach the shorter period of 60 years. If 600 were simply ten repetitions of a 60-year lunisolar cycle, we might expect ten times the shorter lunar count to produce the longer one. It does not quite do so. Sixty tropical years contain about 742.096 lunations. If we approximate that as 742 lunar months and repeat the block ten times, we obtain only 7 420 months. But the 600-year approximation requires 7 421. That extra month is revealing.

The longer period is not simply ten identical copies of the shorter one. It absorbs the accumulated error of the shorter approximation. Ten 60-year blocks produce a discrepancy large enough that an additional lunation enters the count: 10 × 742 + 1 = 7 421.

This is exactly the sort of thing we should expect in a system built from approximate astronomical cycles. A smaller block provides a convenient working unit; a larger block corrects the error that accumulates within it.

And the 360-unit calculation displays the same principle in another form. At 60 schematic years, the 248-day cycle leaves a remainder of 24 days. At 600 years that remainder has become 240 days, almost another complete 248-day period. Again, the remainder is accumulating towards a correction.

Twelve lunar months do not make a solar year, so an additional month is periodically inserted. A 365-day civil year does not equal the actual solar year, so the discrepancy accumulates until another correction becomes necessary. The same principle can operate at much larger scales.

This raises the possibility that 60 and 600 were not rival astronomical periods at all. Sixty may have been a convenient computational block, while 600 provided a higher-order correction. And 3 600 years, another period which both Bailly and Le Gentil encountered, would take the same architecture one stage further.

The sixty-year cycle also had a more practical application in everyday life, serving as a means of reckoning historical time, rather as we use centuries today. Le Gentil explains that the Indians employed recurring periods of sixty years to date important events, particularly the reigns and deaths of rulers. He illustrates this with the death of Salivaganam, whom he describes as a restorer of Indian astronomy, traditionally dated to AD 78. To establish how many years had elapsed since his death, the astronomers multiplied 22 completed sixty-year periods by 60, giving 1 320 years, and added 22 years from the current cycle. They then added a further 349 years, arriving at 1 691 years, the interval between AD 78 and 1769.

What particularly interested Le Gentil was the manner in which the additional 349 years were expressed. Rather than stating the number directly, his informants represented it through three symbolic numbers: 9, 4 and 3, associated respectively with the Vedam, its four books, and three kinds of sacred fire. These numbers were then arranged according to a particular convention to produce 349. Le Gentil regarded this as an unnecessarily mysterious way of concealing a simple calculation, remarking that almost all their astronomical calculations were similarly veiled. Whatever his judgement of the practice, the example shows how the sixty-year period functioned as a recurring chronological unit, while a separate numerical convention allowed dates to be recorded and communicated within that framework.


The sixty-year period also belonged, according to Le Gentil, to a much larger astronomical framework. He observed that the periods of 60, 600 and 3 600 years could all be related to a supposed precession of the equinoxes of 54 arcseconds per year. At this rate, the equinoctial point would move through 54 arcminutes in 60 years, 9 degrees in 600 years, and 54 degrees in 3 600 years, completing the full circle of 360 degrees in 24 000 years. The larger period therefore contained exactly 400 cycles of 60 years, or 40 cycles of 600 years. Le Gentil regarded these relationships as evidence of an underlying astronomical rationale for the periods, and even suggested a possible connection with the ancient Chaldean periods described by Berossus. Whether or not these historical connections can be established, the mathematical structure is striking: the same recurring periods that served to organise historical chronology could also be expressed as precise divisions of a much larger celestial revolution.


More recently, Robert Temple has written about the period of 60 years associated with the Dogon of Mali:


The Sigui among the Dogon is celebrated every sixty years... The Egyptians had such a period associated with Osiris [principle of renwal]... My own predilection, when considering the period of sixty years, is to think in terms of a synchronisation of the orbital periods of the two planets, Jupiter and Saturn, for they come together in nearly sixty years ... Stonehenge has sixty stones in its outer circle... (This) outer circle is the oriental cycle of Vrihaspati... It is therefore interesting that the dogon say that sixty is the count of the cosmic placenta.


John Anthony West, after quoting these words in Serpent in the Sky, writes:


The sixty year cycle also provides a link between the Egyptian Sothic year and the Great Year of the precession of the equinoxes, which bear a relationship to each other similar to the Egyptian civil year of 360 days to the tropical year of 365 days. A precessional 'month' of 2160 years divides into three 'decans' of 720 years each. Two 'great' civil years of 360 years (6 x 60) plus five epagomenal years per 'great' year 2(360 x 5) make up the precessional 'decan' of 730 years. Conceivably, it is this relationship that determined the Egyptian year of 360 + 5 days to begin with; a reckoning which, as far as I know, has not been satisfactorily accounted for otherwise. In any case, 72 Sothic hemidemicycles of 360 years each plus one great epagomenal year (72 x 5 years) make up a precessional year. To construct a pentagon within a circle, it must be divided into 5 72 degree angles, and thus on a grand scale the Sothic and precessional cycles again reflect the relationships between 5 and 6, and their multiples and powers. The sixty-year Dogon cycle and Egyptian Osirian cycle is therefore a 'day' of the precessional scheme, Sirius plays a role similar to that played by Jupiter within the solar system; her Egyptian title of 'Great Provider' perhaps furnishes a clue that further research could elaborate upon.



One period, several clocks


There is another reason not to insist that 60 years must have had a single astronomical explanation. It happens to sit near several quite different celestial rhythms.

Jupiter takes about 11.86 years to orbit the Sun, while Saturn takes about 29.45 years. In sixty years Jupiter therefore completes approximately five revolutions and Saturn approximately two. More strikingly, Jupiter and Saturn come into conjunction about every 19.86 years. Three conjunction intervals amount to roughly 3 × 19.86 ≈ 59.58 years.

So a period of approximately sixty years also marks a larger rhythm of the two slowest visible planets. It is not an exact return, the conjunction shifts around the zodiac. but it is another celestial pattern that fits naturally into the same numerical block.

We tend to ask of an ancient cycle: what does this number represent? But perhaps that is the wrong question. A period such as 60 or 600 may not represent one celestial motion. It may be a common framework within which several motions can be compared.

That would make sense of something otherwise rather puzzling about Le Gentil's investigation. He keeps finding different possible meanings for the same periods. Six hundred years is lunisolar. Then it seems connected with the lunar apogee. Sixty years belongs to chronology, but also sits close to planetary rhythms. The periods expand into 3 600 years and beyond.

Perhaps this multiplicity is not a problem to be solved. Perhaps it is what the system was designed to achieve.

The sky supplies the awkward numbers: 29.53059, 27.55455, 365.2422, and so on. The mathematical system supplies numbers such as 60, 360, 600 and 3 600. Ancient astronomy consists, in part, of finding the places where the two sets come close enough to one another to be useful. Some numbers belong to the grid; others belong to the sky. Ancient astronomy is the art of making them communicate. And if that is what is happening, the next step is to follow the grid itself.

Because the sequence does not end with 600. Le Gentil found 60, 600 and 3,600 embedded within a still larger numerical structure, including a period of 24 000 years. And once 24,000 is brought into the picture, the enormous numbers of the Indian Yugas: 216 000, 432 000, 864 000 and beyond, no longer look quite so remote from the comparatively modest astronomical cycles with which we began.

Period

What is being brought back together

Approximate relationship

What it achieves

4 years

365-day calendar ↔ 365.25-day year

4×365+1=1 461 days

Leap-day correction restores the calendar towards the solar year

8 years

Sun ↔ Moon ↔ Venus

8 tropical years ≈ 99 synodic months ≈ 5 Venus synodic cycles

Approximate return of lunar phases and Venus

Saros: 223 lunations

Lunar phase ↔ nodes ↔ apogee/perigee

223 synodic ≈ 242 draconic ≈ 239 anomalistic months

Similar eclipses recur after about 18 years 11 days

19 years — Metonic

Sun ↔ lunar phase ↔ Moon against stars

19 tropical years ≈ 235 synodic months ≈ 254 sidereal months

Moon returns very nearly to the same phase at the same season, and very nearly to the same stellar position (National Academies)

25 Egyptian civil years

365-day calendar ↔ Moon

25×365=9,12525\times365=9,125 days ≈ 309 synodic months

New Moon returns almost exactly to the same place in the civil calendar

28 years — Julian solar cycle

Leap-year pattern ↔ seven-day week

8 Julian years

Dates return to the same weekdays within the Julian leap-year pattern

60 years

Several lunar and planetary rhythms

≈ 742 lunations; ≈ 3 Jupiter–Saturn conjunction intervals; ≈ 5 Jupiter and 2 Saturn revolutions

Useful shorter framework for several different celestial clocks

600 years

Sun ↔ Moon; longer computational periods

600 tropical years ≈ 7,421 lunations; separately 600 × 360 ≈ 871 × 248 days

Very close long-term lunisolar reconciliation; also connects Le Gentil's 360-day and 248-day calculations

532 years

19-year lunar cycle ↔ 28-year Julian solar cycle

19×28=532

Combines lunar phase/date recurrence with the Julian weekday/leap-year pattern for Easter computation

1 460 / 1 461 years

365-day civil year ↔ 365.25-day year

1461×365 = 1460×365.25

The two year-counts meet exactly in the schematic arithmetic

1 803 years 

Tropical year ↔ lunar phase

1803 tropical years ≈ 22 300 synodic months

Extremely close mathematical lunisolar correspondence; not presented as a historically attested ancient cycle


The System Le Gentil Uncovered



There is another aspect of Le Gentil's account which deserves much closer attention. Until now the 248-day period has been looked at principally as a number: nine anomalistic months amount to almost exactly 248 days. But the tables Le Gentil brought back from India show that the significance of this period was considerably more sophisticated than that.

Le Gentil gives four périodes lunaires des Brames, qui leur servent de diviseur — lunar periods used by the Brahmins as divisors: 1 000 984, 12 372, 3 031, and 248 days.

These numbers form part of an algorithm for calculating the position of the Moon. An accumulated day-count, which Le Gentil calls the chouddhadinam, is divided successively by these periods. After each division the remainder is carried forward and divided by the next period. The resulting quotients are multiplied by corresponding angular quantities and combined. If a remainder remains after division by 248, the astronomer then consults a separate table giving the Moon's motion for each individual day of the 248-day period. Le Gentil demonstrates the procedure with an example beginning from 1 778 701 elapsed days. The three shorter periods are particularly revealing:

248 days ≈ 9 anomalistic months, 3 031 days ≈ 110 anomalistic months, 12 372 days ≈ 449 anomalistic months

Using a mean anomalistic month of 27.55455 days gives:

9 x 27.55455 = 247.99095,

only 0.00905 day short of 248 days;

110 x 27.55455 = 3031.00050, only 0.00050 day, or 43.2 seconds, beyond 3 031 days; and

449 x 27.55455 = 12371.99295,

only 0.00705 day short of 12 372 days.

These are extremely close integer approximations to successive returns of the Moon relative to its apsidal line (the cycle of perigee and apogee).

There is even an intriguing arithmetical relationship between them:

12 372 = 4 (3 031) + 248

while their corresponding numbers of anomalistic revolutions obey precisely the same relationship:

449 = 4 (110) + 9

Thus the numerical architecture in days mirrors the astronomical architecture in anomalistic revolutions.

But the most interesting evidence is not the numbers themselves. It is Le Gentil's 248-day table of daily lunar motion.

The table does not treat the Moon as moving around the heavens at a constant rate, quite the opposite. Le Gentil records a mean daily lunar motion of 791 arcminutes, but the individual daily values in the table oscillate between approximately 722 and 859 arcminutes per day.    

When these figures are plotted, their purpose becomes immediately apparent.

Across the 248 days there are approximately nine complete waves of acceleration and deceleration. This is

exactly what we should expect if the table is organised around nine anomalistic months. As the Moon proceeds through its anomalistic cycle, its apparent motion changes; the table records that inequality rather than suppressing it beneath a uniform average.

This distinction is important. The 248 days provide the repeating computational frame, but the astronomer does not simply divide 360 degrees by 248 and pretend that the Moon advances uniformly through it. The individual daily motion is tabulated. The regular period therefore contains an explicitly irregular motion.

Indeed, the mean of the 248 daily differences transcribed from Le Gentil's table is approximately 790.65'per day, extremely close to the 791′ mean which Le Gentil says the Brahmins assumed. The average and the variation coexist within the same system. The mean provides the mathematical reference; the table preserves the observed inequality.




It also provides a remarkably concrete example of the distinction between the heavens, which do not present the astronomer with neat integer numbers of days or years, and the system built up around observations. The Moon speeds up and slows down. Its synodic, sidereal, anomalistic and draconic revolutions are different lengths. None divides perfectly into the solar year. Yet astronomy requires a stable numerical structure within which these motions can be calculated. The Indian procedure does not solve that problem by pretending the irregularities do not exist. It does something more intelligent: it constructs regular numerical periods around an irregular astronomical phenomenon.

So 248 belongs to the computational structure, the grid, but the varying sequence, such as 722', 730', 800', 859', etc, describes the changing motion occurring within it.

The purpose of the grid is not to make the heavens regular. It is to make their irregularities calculable. This is why the 248-day period matters exactly. Nine anomalistic months do not equal 248 days exactly. The difference is not ignored. Instead, 248 provides a practical integer framework within which the changing motion can be tabulated and carried forward through a larger computational procedure. And the same principle appears at larger scales:

The astronomer moves between integer day-counts and actual celestial motions. 248, 3 031 and 12 372 are not substitutes for observation; they are devices for organising it.


This also helps explain something in Le Gentil which otherwise seems rather puzzling. When discussing the periods of 60, 600 and 3 600 years, he insists that they must be considered from another point of view than merely bringing lunar conjunctions or eclipses back after a fixed interval. The relevant point of view, he says, is the Moon relative to its apogee, what European astronomers called its anomalistic revolution. That now makes much more sense.

Le Gentil had encountered an Indian computational astronomy in which anomalistic motion was not peripheral. It was built directly into the calculation of lunar longitude. The 248-day table itself is evidence of that. And this makes the relationship 600 x 360 = 216000 very interesting, also 871 x 248 = 216008. These two numbers arise from quite different directions. The first belongs to the idealised 360-unit year:

600 x 360 = 216 000 = 60³.

The second is generated by repeatedly applying the smallest anomalistic divisor in the Indian lunar system: 871 x 248 = 216 008. They miss one another by only eight units in more than 216 000. That does not mean that 248 has somehow been derived from 360. In fact, the distinction is what makes the relationship interesting. 360 belongs to the regular numerical grid; 248 derives from the observed behaviour of the Moon. One is mathematically ordered; the other is an integer approximation to an irregular celestial cycle.

The closeness of 216 000 and 216 008 therefore brings us straight back to the central problem of ancient astronomy: how to make the regular language of number communicate with the irregular motions of the heavens.


One of the most interesting consequences of these tables is that we cannot still continue to imagine ancient astronomy as primitive. It is easy to imagine early astronomy as consisting principally of observing risings and settings, recognising simple cycles and recording eclipses. Yet what Le Gentil encountered was computational astronomy of a quite different order. It distinguished mean from variable motion, used nested integer periods, carried remainders through successive divisions, converted the resulting quantities into angular position, and finally consulted a day-by-day table to represent lunar inequality. This is light years from rudimentary astronomy.


What Le Gentil encountered in eighteenth-century India was therefore not merely a collection of ancient numbers. It was a functioning computational astronomy. How far back the particular tables and procedures he recorded can be traced is a separate historical question, and one to which I shall return. What matters here is the nature of the system itself. It distinguishes mean from variable motion; it constructs nested integer approximations to the anomalistic month; and it uses a 248-day table to preserve the Moon's changing speed within a regular numerical framework. This is not an astronomy which mistakes an ideal cycle for the heavens themselves. It knows perfectly well that the heavens are irregular. The purpose of the numerical system is precisely to calculate that irregularity.


The lunar inequality encoded in Le Gentil's 248-day table. The graph plots the daily lunar motion (Différ.) given in the Brahmin table recorded by Le Gentil. The approximately nine repeating oscillations correspond to the nine anomalistic lunar revolutions contained in the 248-day period. The dashed line shows the stated mean lunar motion of 791 arcminutes per day.
The lunar inequality encoded in Le Gentil's 248-day table. The graph plots the daily lunar motion (Différ.) given in the Brahmin table recorded by Le Gentil. The approximately nine repeating oscillations correspond to the nine anomalistic lunar revolutions contained in the 248-day period. The dashed line shows the stated mean lunar motion of 791 arcminutes per day.






Time and Space



We are so accustomed to our divisions of time that they seem natural: hours, minutes, seconds. But minutes and seconds also belong to another system. A degree is divided into sixty minutes, and a minute into sixty seconds.

This is not merely a coincidence of terminology. In astronomy, time and angle are intimately connected, because the heavens appear to move through angles as time passes.

One complete rotation of the Earth corresponds to both a period of time and a circle in space. Twenty-four hours correspond to 360 degrees. One hour of rotation corresponds to 15 degrees; four minutes of time correspond to one degree. We can describe the same rotation by saying how long it takes or how far around the circle it has travelled.

Seen in this light, the schematic year of 360 units becomes much more interesting. It need not represent a mistaken estimate of the number of days in a year. It can function as a coordinate system: a complete revolution in time mapped onto a complete revolution in space.

Bailly was particularly interested in the fact that Indian astronomical reckoning used sexagesimal divisions of the day. The same culture could use other divisions for civil purposes. For him, that distinction mattered. Sexagesimal reckoning belonged particularly to astronomical calculation: it was a mathematical language for describing movement.

And this brings us to one of the most intriguing numbers encountered by Le Gentil.


54 Seconds and 24 000 Years


Among the Indian astronomical values reported by Le Gentil was an annual motion of the stars of 54 arcseconds. He interpreted this as a value connected with the precession of the equinoxes. Whatever its original interpretation, the arithmetic is beautifully simple.

There are 60 arcseconds in an arcminute and 60 arcminutes in a degree. A complete circle therefore contains:

360 × 60 × 60 = 1 296 000 arcseconds.

If the stellar sphere moves by 54 arcseconds each year, one complete revolution requires:

1 296 000 ÷ 54 = 24 000 years.

So the apparently enormous period of 24 000 years is simply a circle translated into time.

And the smaller periods we have already encountered now acquire angular values of their own. At 54 arcseconds per year:

60 years = 54 arcminutes = 0.9°

600 years = 9°

3 600 years = 54°

24 000 years = 360°

This was the point at which the system began to look quite different to me. Sixty, 600 and 3 600 were no longer simply periods of years. They could also represent stages in a rotation.

Le Gentil regarded the 24 000-year period as an ancient estimate of precession. That may indeed have been its purpose. The modern precessional period is closer to 26 000 years, so 24 000 is not an especially accurate value by comparison with some of the lunar periods we have been examining.

But there is another possibility. The equation works equally well in reverse.

If you begin with a Great Year of 24 000 years and divides the complete circle by it, the resulting motion is automatically:

360° ÷ 24 000 = 54″ per year.

So which came first? Was 24 000 derived from an observed stellar motion of 54″ per year? Or was 54″ the rate implied by an already established 24 000-year cycle?

The arithmetic cannot answer that question.

What it does show is that 24 000 converts time into angular motion using exactly the same sexagesimal subdivisions that we still use for angles today.

There is another reason why 24 000 is interesting: it contains exactly forty periods of 600 years, or 400 periods of 60 years:

24 000 = 40 × 600 = 400 × 60.

It also contains exactly 3 000 eight-year periods. The eight-year cycle is about the relationship between the Sun, Moon and Venus. Three eight-year periods produce 24 years; twenty-five such 24-year blocks produce 600 years; and forty 600-year periods produce 24 000:

8 × 3 = 24

24 × 25 = 600

600 × 40 = 24 000.

This doesn't prove the system was historically constructed in this order. But it does show how naturally the periods can be nested. An eight-year astronomical cycle can be carried into 24, 600 and finally 24 000 years without leaving a framework of simple integer multiplication. And then the Indian Yugas enter the picture.



The Yugas



Yuga cycles, Bondigoldwiki, Wikimedia COmmons
Yuga cycles, Bondigoldwiki, Wikimedia COmmons

The traditional Indian system of Yugas initially seems to belong to an entirely different scale of thought. Instead of decades or centuries, we suddenly encounter hundreds of thousands and millions of years. The four Yugas are conventionally given as:

Kali Yuga: 432 000 years

Dvapara Yuga: 864 000 years

Treta Yuga: 1 296 000 years

Krita Yuga: 1 728 000 years

Together they form the Mahāyuga of 4 320 000 years.

The familiar relationship between them is 1 : 2 : 3 : 4. But once the 24 000-year period has been introduced, another pattern appears:

432 000 = 18 × 24 000

864 000 = 36 × 24 000

1 296 000 = 54 × 24 000

1 728 000 = 72 × 24 000.

So the four Yugas are simply:

18, 36, 54 and 72 periods of 24 000 years.

The sequence 18, 36, 54, 72 is itself merely 18 multiplied by 1, 2, 3 and 4. The traditional Yuga proportions and the 24 000-year period therefore fit perfectly together.

Their sum gives:

180 × 24 000 = 4 320 000.

This does not in itself tell us what the Yugas originally meant. But it makes it difficult to regard their enormous durations simply as extravagant numbers chosen for effect. They have an extremely orderly mathematical construction.

And there is a second route to exactly the same numerical family.

We have already seen that:

600 × 360 = 216 000 = 60³.

Double it:

2 × 600 × 360 = 432 000.

But we have just arrived at the same number through the 24 000-year period:

18 × 24 000 = 432 000.

So:

2 × 600 × 360 = 18 × 24 000 = 432 000.

The first Yuga value can therefore be reached either through the 600-year period and the 360-unit revolution, or through eighteen revolutions of 24 000 years.

The complete Mahāyuga has the same structure:

4 320 000 = 20 × 216 000 = 20 × 60³.

A complete circle expressed in arcseconds contains: 360 × 60 × 60 = 1 296 000 arcseconds.

But 1 296 000 is also the duration of the Treta Yuga.

And because the 24,000-year cycle implies 54 arcseconds per year:

54 × 24 000 = 1 296 000.

So the same number can be generated in three ways:

360 × 60 × 60 = 54 × 24 000 = 1 296 000.

One expression describes a circle divided sexagesimally. Another describes angular movement accumulated through time. The third appears as one of the great periods of Indian cosmology.

Perhaps these vast “years” should not automatically be read in the same way that we read an ordinary solar year. They may preserve numerical structures whose original astronomical functions became absorbed into chronology and cosmology. That was, after all, close to Bailly's suspicion: ancient traditions might preserve the numbers long after the system that


We need to keep in mind the different meanings of a year. The tropical year, measured by the return of the Sun to the equinox, is approximately 365.2422 days, while the sidereal year, measured relative to the fixed stars, is approximately 365.25636 days. A civil year belongs to a calendar and may contain 365 or 366 days, or follow a different arrangement altogether. The idealised year of 360 units, meanwhile, is a mathematical construction, providing a convenient framework for calculation rather than necessarily representing an observed astronomical duration.


These distinctions become particularly important when considering the enormous periods of Indian astronomy. In the Āryabhaṭīya, composed around AD 499, Aryabhata assigns 4 320 000 revolutions of the Sun and 57 753 336 revolutions of the Moon to a Yuga. The resulting relationship corresponds to sidereal, rather than tropical, reckoning. By contrast, the shorter periods of 60 and 600 years discussed by Le Gentil may serve chronological or computational purposes without always specifying which astronomical year is intended. It's important to bear in mind the difference between the natural cycles being measured, the calendar years used to count them, and the ideal numerical units in which their relationships are expressed. The fact that the same numbers recur in these different contexts does not mean that the units themselves are interchangeable.generated them had been forgotten.



A Brief Return to Giza


Several of the numbers that had emerged independently from the astronomy were already familiar from my work on the pyramids. The Giza relationships don't prove anything here, but they provide interesting parallels. The numbers 19, 223, 248 or 254 already have independent astronomical meanings. The first example involves the two best-known ancient lunar cycles. The Metonic cycle contains nineteen solar years; the Saros contains 223 synodic months. Multiply the two numbers:

19 × 223 = 4 237.

Double this:

2 × 4 237 = 8 474.

Petrie's measured side of the Second Pyramid is approximately 8 474.9 inches. The difference is less than one inch. There is even a geometrical curiosity here: φ³ is approximately 4.236068, extremely close to 4.237. I would not want to build an argument upon that coincidence, but it is worth noting in a system in which astronomical and geometrical ratios may have been deliberately brought together.

The larger pattern arose from what I call the Great Giza Rectangle, whose length from Petrie's survey is approximately 35 713.2 inches. I had found that astronomical ratios involving the Metonic and Saros numbers transform this length into dimensions remarkably close to those of the pyramids.

For example:

35 713.2 × 223 / 235 = 33 889.55 inches.

This is close to the perimeter of the Second Pyramid, approximately 33,899.6 inches from Petrie's side measurement of 8 474.9 inches.

Using the sidereal-month count of the Metonic cycle:

35 713.2 × 254 / 1,000 = 9 071.15 inches,

compared ith Petrie's Great Pyramid side of approximately 9 068.8 inches.

And:

35,713.2 × 29.53059 / 254 = 4 152.09 inches,

which falls in the range of the Third Pyramid side measurements.

Again, these are numerical correspondences, not by themselves evidence of historical intention. But the reason I find them worth pursuing is that the numbers being used are not selected from nowhere. 19, 223, 235 and 254 belong to actual ancient astronomical cycles.

Le Gentil's 248-day period now adds another.

Divide the Great Giza Rectangle length by 248:

35 713.2 ÷ 248 = 144.00484...

Or reverse it:

248 × 144 = 35,712 inches.

That is just 1.2 inches short of the measured length of 35 713.2 inches.

And 144 is itself 12².

This one particularly interests me because 248 is not an obvious number to go looking for in a pyramid. It became significant for quite another reason: Le Gentil found a 248-day period operating in Indian lunar calculations, and nine anomalistic months are 247.99095 days. Only after understanding that did the Giza relationship acquire any astronomical meaning for me.

It does not prove that the Great Giza Rectangle was designed as 144 periods of 248 inches. But it gives me another reason to keep asking whether the astronomical numbers and the dimensions are speaking the same mathematical language.

There may be another way of thinking about the two principal axes at Giza. The north–south line is meridional: extended conceptually beyond the surface of the Earth, it belongs to the polar framework and the celestial axis about which the heavens appear to turn. The east–west line, by contrast, belongs naturally to the daily movement of the Sun, from sunrise to sunset, and to the equatorial circle swept out by the daily rotation of the heavens. This suggests a distinction between two forms of astronomical time. East–west and equatorial movement belong naturally to the day; north–south and meridional movement to the year, since the annual solar cycle reveals itself observationally through the changing declination of the Sun, moving north and south between its solstitial limits. It is interesting in this context that the metrological pattern I have been exploring appears to make a similar distinction, associating the equatorial circumference with the inch and astronomical periods expressed in days, while the polar circumference seems to belong to another family of measures.   

Plato provides a striking image with which to think about this geometry. In the Timaeus, the axis and circles of the cosmos belong to its geometrical construction before the visible celestial bodies are introduced as the instruments by which time is numbered. Only afterwards does the Demiurge, as it were, switch on the lights: Sun, Moon and planets are placed into their circuits, and their movements make the different measures of time perceptible, and only then is the sun lit up. Something similar may be useful as a way of thinking about Giza. Before there are days, months or years to count, there is an axis and a geometrical framework: north and south, east and west, pole and equator, meridian and horizon. The celestial bodies then move through that framework. Daily rotation gives the east–west circle its measure; annual solar motion gives the north–south dimension its changing measure. If Giza was conceived astronomically, its cardinal geometry may therefore have been more than orientation towards particular celestial events. It could have provided the coordinate framework within which different kinds of celestial time were expressed.


From the Great Year to the Measure of the Earth



Astronomy naturally converts time into angle. But angle also converts directly into distance once a circle is given a physical size. A degree on the Earth's surface is both an angle at the centre of the Earth and a distance travelled around its circumference. Divide the terrestrial circle into 360 degrees, each degree into sixty minutes and each minute into sixty seconds, and the sexagesimal system becomes a system of geodesy.

A complete terrestrial circle contains 360 × 60 × 60 = 1 296 000 arcseconds.

We have just encountered that number in the Yuga system.

This made me wonder whether some of the ancient units of length I had been studying might belong to the same conversation.

The equatorial circumference of the Earth is approximately 24 901.461 miles. Expressed in inches, this is:

24, 01.461 × 63 360 = 1 577 756 568.96 inches.

Now compare this with the Mahāyuga number of 4 320 000.

Dividing the terrestrial circumference by 4 320 000 gives:

1 577 756 568.96 ÷ 4 320 000 = 365.221428...

That immediately looks familiar. It is extremely close to the number of days in a year.

The comparison can also be reversed. If I take the tropical year of 365.2422 days and multiply it by the Mahāyuga number:

4 320 000 × 365.2422 = 1 577 846,304 inches.

The actual equatorial circumference used above is:

1 577 756 568.96 inches.

The difference is about 89,735 inches, or approximately 1.42 miles, around the entire circumference of the Earth.

In percentage terms, the discrepancy is only about 0.0057%.

I find that difficult simply to ignore.

The relationship can be written another way because:

4 320 000 = 60 × 60 × 12 × 100.

So the constructed circumference is:

60 × 60 × 12 × 100 × 365.2422 inches.

Here again a number of days in an astronomical year, a sexagesimal structure and a terrestrial distance appear in the same equation.

It is important to distinguish what I am doing here from the earlier historical evidence. I do not have an ancient text saying that the inch was defined by dividing the Earth's circumference in this way. This is my own metrological hypothesis. But it arose from my work on Giza, where I had increasingly come to suspect that the inch, or something extremely close to it, was the fundamental unit behind the dimensions, as well as observations made by Robin Heath.

There is another intriguing terrestrial value. A figure I have used for the polar circumference is approximately 1 575 000 000 inches. Unlike the modern equatorial figure above, this is an idealised round value, but its structure is extraordinary 1 575 000 000 = 360 × 4 375 000,

and it sits within the same broad world of highly structured terrestrial circumference numbers found in ancient metrology.

The question is therefore no longer simply whether one ancient culture knew the circumference of the Earth to some particular degree of accuracy. It is whether units of length themselves could have been generated from astronomical and terrestrial divisions.

That would dissolve some of the distinction we instinctively make between time and space.

A day measures a rotation. A degree measures part of that rotation. An arcminute and arcsecond subdivide the degree. On the surface of a sphere, those angular divisions correspond to distances. If the unit of length is then defined in relation to one of those distances, the same mathematical system has travelled all the way from time, to angle, to terrestrial measure. Perhaps that is what we are looking at.


What Survived?


At the beginning of this investigation, the 600-year Great Year looked like an isolated curiosity. Josephus had preserved the number; Cassini had rediscovered its extraordinary lunisolar accuracy; Bailly wondered why such an excellent period had apparently been forgotten.

Six hundred schematic revolutions of 360 units produced 216 000 = 60³. Le Gentil's peculiar 248-day lunar period came within eight days of an integer relationship with those 216 000 units. A stellar movement of 54 arcseconds per year produced a complete revolution in 24 000 years. That period contained forty 600-year cycles. The Yugas were exact multiples of 24 000, while their smallest value, 432 000, could also be produced simply by doubling 600 × 360. The complete Mahāyuga was twenty times 60³.

And throughout it all, the same sexagesimal grammar kept reappearing: 60, 360, 600, 3 600, 24 000, 216 000, 432 000, 1 296 000, 4320 000.

Some of these numbers arise from observations. Some are mathematical constructions. Some belong securely to particular historical astronomical traditions; others are connections I have made while trying to reconstruct the system.

Bailly's image of ancient astronomy as débris, orscattered fragments of something once more coherent, keept returning to me. He imagined a very ancient science whose pieces had survived separately among different peoples. I would push the possibility much further back in time than Bailly could reasonably have done in the eighteenth century. The antiquity of humanity, and therefore the possible depth of accumulated observation, is vastly greater than he knew.

Perhaps the sexagesimal system itself is one of the largest surviving fragments.

We still divide the circle into 360 degrees. We still divide degrees into sixty minutes and minutes into sixty seconds. We still divide time sexagesimally. These conventions have survived every transformation of astronomy, geography and measurement around them.

Convenience is certainly part of the answer. Sixty is a wonderfully divisible number. But that does not tell us when the system was created, why it was first applied simultaneously to time and angle, or how far its original architecture extended.

My suspicion is that the answer lies much further back than the surviving written evidence.

If the reconstruction attempted here is even partly correct, the great periods of ancient astronomy may not be an assortment of unrelated inventions made by Babylonians, Egyptians, Indians, Greeks and others at different moments. Some may be local developments; others certainly were refined over time. But beneath them there may survive an older computational language: a way of mapping the imperfect cycles of the heavens onto a stable numerical grid.

The sky does not run on sixty. The tropical year is not 360 days. The lunar month does not divide neatly into anything. The planets stubbornly refuse to return on schedule.

That may be precisely why the system was needed.

Some numbers belong to the grid; others belong to the sky. Ancient astronomy was the art of making them communicate. And perhaps, every time we look at a clock or measure an angle in degrees, minutes and seconds, we are still using a small piece of that forgotten language.



The Debris of a Science?


One final characteristic of this numerical system encountered both in astronomy and in ancient metrology is that the scale can change while the numerical structure remains the same. Numbers acquire a zero, or lose one; a period is multiplied by ten, by one hundred, or by 360; yet the underlying relationships are preserved. We have already seen this happening between 60 and 600, and again as the much larger Indian periods are generated from smaller numerical structures. A period of 600 schematic years contains 216 000 units; doubled, this becomes 432 000, the duration assigned to the Kali Yuga. The Mahāyuga expands the same family to 4 320 000.

The system was not purely sexagesimal. In fact, research into ancient metrology suggests the opposite. The sexagesimal system seems to have been intended to work alongside a decimal one. Sixty provides the extraordinary divisibility required for fractions, angles and astronomical cycles, while ten provides a simple means of changing scale.

This is easily overlooked because we tend to speak of “decimal”, “duodecimal” and “sexagesimal” systems as though a culture must choose between them. But there is no mathematical reason why it should. A practical system can use different bases for different operations, and combine them when useful. Indeed, some of the numbers encountered here seem almost to invite precisely that treatment.

Thus 60 becomes 600 simply by changing the decimal scale. The square of 60 gives 3,600. Six times 60 gives the 360 divisions of the circle. Six hundred times 360 gives 216 000, or 60³. Double that and we have 432 000; multiply it by ten and we have 4 320 000. The transformations move backwards and forwards between multiplication by 6, by 60 and by powers of 10.

This is very familiar from metrology. The same underlying numerical value can recur at different orders of magnitude: a unit may be multiplied by ten, one hundred or one thousand while retaining its relationship to the other units around it. What matters is not always the absolute size of the number, but its place within a family of ratios.

That possibility may also change how we approach the enormous numbers of ancient chronology. Perhaps adding zeros did not necessarily imply the discovery of an entirely new astronomical period. It could represent a change of scale within an existing computational structure. Multiplication by 360 could perform another kind of transformation, converting one category of “year” or period into another.

The Indian Yuga system provides a particularly striking example. Its traditional figures can be generated from smaller numbers by multiplication by 360: 1 200 becomes 432 000; 2 400 becomes 864 000; 3 600 becomes 1 296 000; and 4 800 becomes 1 728 000. The four smaller numbers themselves preserve the simple proportion 1:2:3:4. The apparent enormity of the resulting chronology may therefore conceal an extremely simple numerical architecture.

This makes me reluctant to assume that an ancient number such as 432 000 must originally have meant precisely “432 000 ordinary solar years” in the modern sense. It may have done. But before making that assumption, we should ask what happens when the number is divided, rescaled or converted through the other operations of the system.

And this is perhaps another way of recognising Bailly's débris. What survives may sometimes be the number after the operation has been performed, while the rule that generated it has disappeared.


Bailly was confronted by a problem that has never entirely gone away. When he looked at the earliest astronomical traditions known to him in Chaldea, India, China and elsewhere, he did not think they looked like the tentative beginnings of a science. They looked strangely uneven. Sophisticated methods existed alongside apparently elementary gaps in understanding; accurate numbers survived without clear explanations of how they had been obtained; observations had been preserved whose original purpose was no longer obvious.

This led him to one of the most striking statements in his work:

« Quand on considère avec attention l'état de l'Astronomie dans la Chaldée, dans l'Inde & à la Chine, on y trouve plutôt les débris que les élémens d'une science. »
“When we consider attentively the state of astronomy in Chaldea, India and China, we find there the debris of a science rather than its elements.”

That distinction between débris and élémens is crucial. Bailly was suggesting that what appeared in the earliest surviving records might not represent astronomy being invented. It might represent fragments of something older being preserved, copied and sometimes used without the principles behind it being fully understood.

He went further:

« Les instituteurs des connaissances astronomiques, chez les différens peuples, ont donc des ancêtres communs qui paroissent être les vrais auteurs de ces connaissances. »
“The teachers of astronomical knowledge among the different peoples therefore have common ancestors, who appear to have been the true authors of this knowledge.”

Bailly believed that by around 3000 BC astronomy was already reappearing after an earlier period of loss. I cannot demonstrate that history, and I do not think we need to accept the particular civilisation he eventually imagined in order to take his question seriously. What interests me is the observation behind it. How much of the astronomy that first appears in writing was already inherited?

The 600-year period is a good example of the problem. It appears in the historical material as something already ancient and obscure. Cassini discovered that it produced an extraordinarily good lunisolar period: 600 tropical years correspond very closely to 7 421 synodic months. Bailly was astonished that such a useful period could have been known and then apparently forgotten.

Le Gentil approached the problem differently. Working directly with Indian astronomers and their tables, he found that 600 years could not simply be dismissed as an unnecessarily long alternative to the nineteen-year cycle. It belonged to a family of periods including 60, 600 and 3 600 years, and those periods seemed to intersect with other forms of lunar calculation. In particular, his investigation of the 248-day period led him towards the Moon's anomalistic motion and its apogee. He concluded that:

« Ces périodes de 600 ans ont un rapport évident avec l'apogée de la Lune, ce qui prouve que les Anciens avoient fait une étude assez profonde de la théorie de cet astre. »
“These periods of 600 years have an evident relationship with the Moon's apogee, which proves that the ancients had made a fairly profound study of the theory of this celestial body.”

This seems to me more important than deciding whether every reconstruction proposed by Bailly or Le Gentil was correct. Both men had recognised the same underlying problem. The numbers appeared to belong to a system whose original logic was no longer entirely visible.

My own investigation has led me to wonder whether that system was broader still.

The 600-year period is an excellent lunisolar period when measured against the real tropical year. But 600 also belongs naturally to sexagesimal arithmetic. Combined with the schematic revolution of 360 units, it gives:

600 × 360 = 216,000 = 60³.

Le Gentil's 24 000-year period extends the structure in another direction. At an annual stellar movement of 54 arcseconds, 24 000 years correspond to a complete revolution of 360 degrees. It contains forty periods of 600 years and 400 periods of sixty years.

Then the enormous Indian Yuga numbers fall naturally onto the same grid:

432 000 = 18 × 24 000

864 000 = 36 × 24 000

1 296 000 = 54 × 24 000

1 728 000 = 72 × 24 000

and together:

4 320 000 = 180 × 24 000 = 20 × 60³.

Perhaps these are simply the products of several historical traditions which happened to favour highly divisible numbers. That possibility cannot be excluded. Numerical coherence by itself does not give us a date, a place or a people.

But neither does the first surviving written appearance of a number tell us when it was invented.

So how old is the sexagesimal astronomical system? There is a good case that its essential architecture was already old by the third millennium BC. By then we are not looking merely at people noticing that the Moon returns every month or that the seasons repeat. We encounter organised calendars, long astronomical periods, numerical schemes, angular divisions and methods for reconciling celestial motions that do not naturally fall into whole numbers. How much further back those ideas go is much harder to establish. My suspicion is that they go considerably further.

Perhaps 60 began simply because it is an exceptionally useful calculating number. Perhaps 360 emerged because six sixties make an extraordinarily divisible representation of a complete revolution. Perhaps generations of observers then discovered that real celestial periods could be mapped onto this grid with remarkable effectiveness. Or perhaps some of these relationships were discovered first and helped to determine the grid itself. We cannot yet know which direction the process took.

The 600-year period may provide a glimpse of that process because it seems to stand exactly at the boundary. It is mathematically elegant, yet astronomically effective. It belongs to the grid, but it also fits the sky.

The same may be true of 24 000. It is forty periods of 600 years, but it is also a complete 360-degree rotation at 54 arcseconds per year. The same may be true of the Yugas, whose immense durations resolve into orderly multiples of 24 000 and powers and multiples of sixty. And perhaps the persistence of the same numerical language in the measurement of angles, time and, in the hypothesis I have been exploring, terrestrial distance is not accidental either.

Perhaps what survived was not a sexagesimal system in isolation at all, but a numerical language in which decimal scaling and sexagesimal division worked together. Ten changed the scale; sixty divided and recombined it; 360 mapped it onto a complete revolution. The same operations could then be applied to days, years, angles, astronomical periods and, perhaps, units of distance.

If so, the recurrence of 60, 600, 3 600, 24 000, 216 000, 432 000 and 4 320 000 becomes more interesting than the recurrence of any one number. What matters is the grammar connecting them.

We can ask whether a number has an independent astronomical meaning before looking for it elsewhere. We can distinguish quantities generated by observation from those generated by a mathematical grid. We can examine whether the same numbers repeatedly translate between lunar periods, solar years, planetary cycles and angular movement. We can look for the same structures in surviving systems of chronology and measurement. And, where the evidence ends, we can say so, and then ask what reconstruction best explains what remains.

In that sense, I think Bailly's word débris remains wonderfully apt.

A fragment does not tell us what the whole object looked like. But enough fragments can begin to show that there was a whole.

Bailly believed that the scattered astronomical knowledge of the ancient world pointed backwards towards common ancestors. Le Gentil, working through the calculations themselves, found periods whose functions seemed deeper and more complicated than their surviving explanations suggested.

And perhaps the strangest possibility is that part of the answer has never disappeared at all. We still measure the turning Earth in hours, minutes and seconds. We still divide the circle into degrees, minutes and seconds. The notation survives on our clocks, maps and instruments, even though its beginnings are lost.

If Bailly was right that we possess the débris rather than the beginnings of an ancient science, then the sexagesimal system may be one of its largest surviving pieces.



Comparison of the Moon's apparent size at lunar perigee and apogee, Wikimedia Commons
Comparison of the Moon's apparent size at lunar perigee and apogee, Wikimedia Commons

Conclusion


There have been a great many numbers in this investigation, and it would be easy to lose sight of the larger picture. For me, eight conclusions stand out.


1. Ancient astronomy is not necessarily what we imagine it to have been. What Le Gentil encountered in India was not simply a collection of observations of phases, eclipses, risings and settings. It was a computational astronomy capable of distinguishing different kinds of lunar motion and of following them over extremely long periods. The surviving tables reveal something considerably more sophisticated than a simple calendar. They combine observation with arithmetic procedures, successive divisions, remainders and tables of variable motion. Indian mathematical astronomy used an epoch corresponding to the beginning of the Kali Yuga, on 18 February 3102 BC, and Bailly, comparing the Tirvalore tables with other Indian tables, independently identified their epoch as midnight between 17 and 18 February 3102 BC. The significance of this date has been debated ever since. Bailly and Playfair believed that some of the astronomical parameters preserved genuine observations from this remote period; later historians have argued instead that the epoch was constructed retrospectively by astronomers many centuries later. The tables themselves therefore cannot simply be dated to 3102 BC. What is certain is that Le Gentil encountered the surviving form of a sophisticated computational tradition whose calculations were organised around an epoch nearly five thousand years before his own time.


2. There is no single lunar cycle. This sounds obvious once stated, but it is fundamental to understanding the system. The Moon can return relative to the Sun, giving the synodic month; relative to the stars, giving the sidereal month; relative to perigee and apogee, giving the anomalistic month; or relative to its nodes, giving the draconic month. These are not four slightly different measurements of the same event. They answer four different astronomical questions. Ancient lunar astronomy therefore confronted the problem of reconciling several clocks which never quite agree.


3. The inequality of the Moon's motion is fundamental. The Moon does not travel around the Earth at a constant speed. Its elliptical orbit means that its distance and orbital velocity vary, and the anomalistic month measures its return relative to the line of apsides, from perigee through apogee and back again. The extraordinary 248-day table recorded by Le Gentil does not ignore this irregularity: it tracks it day by day. Across approximately nine anomalistic months, the table records the Moon repeatedly accelerating and decelerating, from about 722 to 859 arcminutes of daily motion, around a stated mean of 791 arcminutes.

This is important because it tells us that the astronomers responsible for the system were not simply imposing beautiful numbers upon the heavens. They knew perfectly well that the heavens departed from the mean, and they preserved those departures numerically.

4. Behind those observations is a grid. Regular numbers and irregular celestial movements coexist. The 360 divisions of a circle, the schematic 360-day year, the periods of 60, 600 and 3 600, and the nested lunar divisors provide stable computational frameworks. Within those frameworks, observations and tables preserve the actual variations of celestial motion.

This also changes how we should think about remainders. Nine anomalistic months do not equal 248 days exactly. Six hundred tropical years do not equal 7 421 synodic months exactly. The point of such systems need not have been to abolish these discrepancies. A remainder tells the astronomer when the mathematical model and the heavens have begun to separate and when a correction or intercalation is required. A remainder is not necessarily evidence that the system has failed; it is information.

The distinction Bailly makes between real celestial time and the hypothetical 360-day year therefore becomes crucial. A 360-day computational year need not imply that anyone believed the actual solar year contained only 360 ordinary days. Complete revolution can be represented by 360 equal divisions. Rotation then provides the bridge between time and angle. The same mathematical language can describe a circle in the heavens, a cycle in time, and ultimately a position on the Earth.


5. The mathematics itself is often simple; what is sophisticated is the architecture. There is nothing especially advanced about multiplication, division and remainders. Yet very simple operations, combined with sufficiently careful observation, can model extraordinarily complicated phenomena.

The Indian lunar periods provide a beautiful example. The periods of 248, 3 031 and 12 372 days correspond extremely closely to 9, 110 and 449 anomalistic months respectively. Moreover,

12 372 = 4 × 3 031 + 248

while

449 = 4 × 110 + 9.

The same arithmetic relationship therefore exists in the day-count and in the number of anomalistic revolutions. The sophistication lies not in complicated algebra, but in knowing what to measure, what to compare, which periods to select, and how to construct a numerical system in which the motions can be calculated.

Perhaps the ancient astronomical problem can be reduced to three questions: return, irregularity and coordinate. When does a celestial body return? How does its motion vary between returns? And relative to what is its position being measured? The long periods address return; the 248-day table addresses irregularity; the 360-degree circle provides the coordinate framework. A mature astronomy requires all three.


6. At the centre of this investigation stands the amazing period of 600 years. Six hundred tropical years amount to 219 145.32 days. That interval comes remarkably close to 7 421 synodic months, 8 021 sidereal months and 7 953 anomalistic months. Three different lunar clocks, these being the moon relative to sun, to the stars and to the apsides, therefore approach whole-number counts within the same six-century period. The draconic month does not fit 600 years as closely. But multiplying the period by ten produces another remarkable result: 6 000 tropical years come extraordinarily close to 80 532 draconic months.

This is why the 600-year period begins to look like something more interesting than simply another “great year”. The Metonic cycle brings solar years and lunar phases into a useful relationship. The Saros brings synodic, anomalistic and draconic months into a relationship useful for the recurrence of eclipses. The 600/6 000-year framework appears, on a vastly larger scale, to bring several of these different lunar clocks into a common numerical field.

Perhaps the purpose of a great period was never to make one celestial cycle return perfectly. Perhaps it provided a sufficiently large framework in which several mutually incommensurable cycles could be reconciled at once.


7. This brings us back to the number 6. Six is already an unusual number mathematically:

1 + 2 + 3 = 6

and

1 × 2 × 3 = 6.

It is the first perfect number. Combined with decimal scaling and sexagesimal multiplication, it generates an extraordinary family:

6 × 10 = 60

6 × 60 = 360

6 × 100 = 600

6 × 1 000 = 6 000

60² = 3 600

and

600 × 360 = 216 000 = 60³.

This suggests that what we are looking at may not have been a purely sexagesimal system at all. Decimal and sexagesimal operations appear naturally together. Ten changes the scale; six and sixty organise the divisions.

And from here we enter more speculative territory. Perhaps the prominence of 6 was not originally arbitrary or purely symbolic. If astronomers discovered that periods generated from this numerical family were extraordinarily effective at organising real celestial motions, the number itself might have acquired cosmological significance. Perhaps six was not used because it was sacred. Perhaps, at least in part, it became sacred because it worked.

This is also where the wider family of what John Michell called harmonic numbers becomes difficult to ignore: 108, 216, 432, 864, 1 080, 1 296, 4 320 and their decimal expansions. They occur in very different contexts, and recurrence alone cannot demonstrate common origin. But they are mathematically related rather than merely visually similar. For example:

108 × 2 = 216

216 × 2 = 432

432 × 2 = 864

54 × 8 = 432

54 × 20 = 1 080

54 × 24 = 1 296

and

216 = 6³.

The enormous Yuga numbers belong to this same numerical family: 432 000, 864 000, 1 296 000 and 1 728 000, with the Mahayuga totalling 4 320 000 years.

The so-called Nineveh constant provides another tantalising example. The enormous number 195 955 200, found on a cuneiform tablet from Nineveh and famously discussed in modern archaeoastronomical literature, factorises as:

195 955 200 = 54 × 10!

and also

195 955 200 = 1 080 × 25 920 × 7.

The recurrence of the same numerical families makes it reasonable to ask whether numbers which later appear in cosmology, chronology, metrology and geometry may sometimes preserve transformations belonging to a common mathematical language.


8. It's not possible to demonstrate that the Indian lunar tables, Babylonian periods, Yuga chronology, Chinese cycles and sexagesimal division of the circle were all parts of one prehistoric system. Nor does the first written appearance of a method tell us when it was invented. What we can say is that the fragments display enough mathematical coherence to make Bailly's question worth asking again. Bailly repeatedly argued that the astronomy surviving in India, Chaldea and China looked less like the beginnings of a science than its debris. Perhaps that is the right image. A fragment cannot tell us exactly what the original object looked like. But when enough fragments begin to fit together, periods, tables, divisions, corrections, harmonic numbers, circles and astronomical returns, it becomes reasonable to ask whether there was once a larger structure to which they belonged.

And there is one final reason why the 600-year period remains so intriguing. It seems to stand exactly where the two halves of this investigation meet.

It belongs to the sky, because 600 real tropical years bring several independent lunar revolutions remarkably close to whole numbers.

But it also belongs to the grid, because:

600 × 360 = 216 000 = 60³.

The same number therefore appears to participate both in the messy, incommensurable motions of actual celestial bodies and in the extraordinarily orderly numerical architecture constructed to measure them. If there was once a larger system behind Bailly's debris, 600 may have stood very close to its heart.


And perhaps it is appropriate to finish with Le Gentil and Bailly, who both lived through extraordinary times, from anomalistic revolutions to the French Revolution. their work allows us to see something of our global inheritance, much of it through India, and glimpse at a science that in many ways continues to live on to this day.


The implications extend beyond the division of time into convenient units. A system that measures both the Moon's revolution and the movement of its apsidal line is already dealing with one cycle unfolding within another moving cycle. If the Moon's varying speed is fundamental to the calculation, then the 360-degree circle is not a representation of uniform celestial motion, but a fixed coordinate system against which non-uniform motion can be measured. The lunar nodes introduce yet another moving reference, and the changing apparent diameter of the Moon brings its varying distance into the calculation. The problem is no longer simply about counting revolutions, it's also about determining how several different revolutions relate to one another, where they diverge, and when they return sufficiently close to their former configurations.


Seen in this light, the sexagesimal system takes on a deeper significance. Sixty is useful because it has so many divisors, but it is also itself the principal divisor through which the circle, the degree, the minute and the second are successively subdivided. It provides a common mathematical language in which different celestial movements can be expressed, compared and reconciled without assuming that they are identical or perfectly commensurable. The great periods of sixty, six hundred or three thousand six hundred years may therefore be understood, at least as a possibility, not simply as immense measures of elapsed time, but as attempts to organise relationships between cycles that never quite coincide. What emerges is an astronomy very different in its methods and representation from our own, but mathematically sophisticated nonetheless: one concerned as much with variation, correction and the accumulation of discrepancies as with regularity and repetition.



Notes


  1. Bailly: “The knowledge here attributed to the earliest men is in no way surprising when we consider that which emerges from the Great Year, or astronomical period of six hundred years, which Josephus attributes to the patriarchs and which was undoubtedly their work. An astronomical period, when it concerns a single celestial body, is the time it takes to travel around the circle it describes. When several celestial bodies are involved, the period of their combined motions is the time which elapses from the moment when they all depart from the same point, or from certain relative positions, until they return to the same point or to the same relative positions. It is clear that a period of this kind must contain an exact number of complete revolutions of each of these bodies. The Great Year of six hundred years must have been a period of this kind, for the ancients called any revolution, whether of one or several planets, a ‘year’. They called a ‘Great Year’ one which encompassed a longer interval. The celebrated Giovanni Domenico Cassini was the first, on considering the account of Josephus, to be struck by the accuracy of this period and by the conclusions that could be drawn from it concerning the length of the year in the time of the patriarchs. He found that 7,421 lunar revolutions of 29 days, 12 hours, 44 minutes and 3 seconds amounted to 219,146½ days, and that the same 219,146½ days gave 600 solar years of 365 days, 5 hours, 51 minutes and 36 seconds, a duration differing by no more than three minutes from that observed today.”

     "Ces connoiffances accordées ici aux premiers hommes n'ont rien d'étonnant , quand on confidere celles qui réfulcenc de la grande année, ou de la période aftronomique de fix cens ans, que Jofeph attribueaux patriarches , & qui eft indubitablement leur ouvrage (1). Une période aftronomique, quand il s'agit d'un aftre feul , eftle tems qu'il employe à parcourir le cercle qu'il décrit. Quand il s'agit de plusieurs aftres , la période de leurs mouvemens combinés eff le cems qui s'écoule depuis qu'ils font tous partis du même point, ou de certains afpeéts , jufqu'à ce qu'ils reviennent au même point , ou aux mêmes afpelts. On voit que cette efpece de période doit comprendre exaéte. ment un nombre de révolutions complettes de chacun de ces aftres, La grande année de fixcens ans doit être une période de ce genre. Car les anciens appelloient année une révolution quelconque , foit d'une ou de plufieurs planetes (2). Ils appelloient grande année celle qui embraffoit un plus long intervalle. Le célebre Dominique Caflini eft le premier qui, ayant fait attention au récit de Jofeph, fut frappé de la jufteffe de cette période, & des conclufions quon en pouvoir tirer fur la longueur de l'année au tems des patriarches, Il trouva que 7421 révolutions lunaires de 29) 12n 44 3" (3), faifoient 219146 jours & demi , & ce même nombre de 219146 & demi donnent 600 années folaires de 365! st 51° 36" ; durée qui ne differe pas de trois minutes de celle qu'on obferve aujourd'hui."

  2. Bailly, Histoire de l'Astronomie Ancienne

  3. Bosak, Jon. 2013. Weights and Measures: From the Ancient World to the Modern. Self-published research, accessed via (99+) The Old Measure









 
 
 

©2018 by Mounds, Hills and Mountains. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page